Seventh-seeded Columbus Crew pulled off a stunning 3-0 upset over defending champions Inter Miami CF in Game 1 of their Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs Round One Best-of-3 series at Nu Stadium on Saturday night, fueled by a clinical Gonzalo Tapia brace and a decisive first-half red card to Gonzalo Lujan.
Advertisement
Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew Player Ratings: Tapia brace stuns Messi in 3-0 MLS Cup shocker

Columbus seized control early when Tapia converted a 9th-minute penalty straight down the middle. Despite trailing, No. 2 seed Inter Miami initially traded blows, creating three first-half big chances as Lionel Messi, German Berterame, and Telasco Segovia all tested Crew goalkeeper Patrick Schulte. However, the tie swung permanently in the 36th minute when Luján was sent off, leaving the hosts to play nearly an hour down a man.
Armed with a numerical advantage, the visitors dismantled Miami’s shape after the break with icy composure. Homegrown attacker Taha Habroune doubled the lead in the 52nd minute off a Brais Mendez assist before Tapia struck again six minutes later to seal a statement road victory. Miami’s frustration boiled over into a flurry of second-half bookings as Columbus managed the closing stages effortlessly ahead of Friday’s Game 2 in Ohio. Here are the full Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew player ratings from Game 1 at Nu Stadium.
Columbus Crew Player Ratings vs Inter Miami
Have a look at the Columbus Crew player ratings from the Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew player ratings.
Goalkeeper
Patrick Schulte - 8: Schulte quietly delivered a top-class cup display. He made four saves, including three inside the box, and twice denied Lionel Messi with strong positioning rather than desperation. What stood out to us was his calm footwork under pressure, even when long balls were awkward. His command of the area on corners eased the strain on his defenders. A couple of loose long passes kept him from an even higher rating, but he was still one of the game’s unsung heroes.
Defenders
Steven Moreira - 8: Moreira played like a veteran full-back in a knockout tie. He completed 74 of 76 passes, which is almost absurd control for an away defender. From our perspective, his assist for Tapia’s second goal at 58 minutes was a key turning point. He pushed high, hit smart long balls, and rarely looked rushed despite Miami’s press. Defensively, he wasn’t tested constantly, but he handled duels well enough and used his experience to draw fouls at smart moments.
Sean Zawadzki - 7.5: The captain’s performance really anchored Columbus at the back. We noticed how he won six of seven duels and both aerials, setting a physical tone early. His five clearances cleaned up several half-dangerous Miami attacks, especially around Berterame. On the ball, 44 accurate passes with 94% success showed his composure. From our perspective, his leadership looked understated yet crucial, barking instructions after the Miami red card to keep everyone focused.
Malte Amundsen - 6.5: Amundsen had a solid but more low-key outing. He hit 31 of 33 passes, mostly safe, and kept possession losses limited. We did notice him losing all three of his recorded duels, which slightly weakened his rating. Still, his positioning and two interceptions helped block central lanes into Messi. From our perspective, he looked conservative, but in a cup tie that caution worked fine.
Advertisement
Midfielders
Dylan Chambost - 6.5: Chambost’s night was neat but not spectacular. He completed 40 of 41 passes, 98% accuracy, which is elite ball security. We noticed his one key pass and one shot on target early helped Columbus settle. However, his yellow card and a couple of fouls hinted at frustration against Miami’s intense midfield. Coming off at 59 minutes felt tactical, to add fresh legs. Overall, a tidy link player who did his job before being withdrawn.
Taha Habroune - 7.5: Habroune’s goal at 52 minutes was the emotional dagger. He timed his run, struck cleanly, and essentially ended any realistic Miami comeback. Beyond the goal, he completed 46 passes at 92% and sprayed three accurate long balls. We noticed he lost many duels and even missed a big chance, which slightly complicates the rating. But his two shots on target, constant movement and defensive work with interceptions made him a standout. From our perspective, he felt like the rhythm setter once Columbus smelled blood.
Anass Zaroury - 7: Zaroury offered subtle control more than highlight moments. He posted 42 accurate passes, frequently recycling with 17 backward balls to maintain tempo. We noticed his work rate, dropping deep to help in tackles and ball recovery. One blocked shot and steady dribbling gave Miami’s right side problems. He still lost half his duels, so it wasn’t flawless. But from our perspective, his positional discipline allowed the more attacking teammates to shine.
Mohamed Farsi - 7: Farsi’s energy up and down the flank was relentless. He completed 43 of 45 passes and pushed forward with three final-third deliveries. What stood out to us was his one big chance created, where his timing and vision split Miami open. Defensively, four ball recoveries and two clearances showed strong commitment. He did lose several duels and got dribbled past once, yet he never looked fazed. Overall, a strong two-way performance that slightly flies under the radar.
Forwards
Brais Méndez - 7.5: Brais was one of those players who grows into knockout games. His assist for Habroune’s goal came from clever movement and a simple yet perfectly weighted pass. We noticed his eight won duels and five dribble attempts, showing strong competitiveness. He completed 42 passes and kept the ball moving, while drawing four fouls to relieve pressure. At times, he risked overcomplicating things and lost possession ten times. Still, from our perspective, his overall impact was clearly positive and decisive.
Santiago Rodríguez - 6.5: Rodríguez had a mixed evening up front. He created three key passes and one big chance, which definitely helped Columbus stretch Miami. But he lost 11 of 15 duels and turned the ball over often. We noticed he kept trying difficult dribbles, sometimes more out of frustration than opportunity. His willingness to draw fouls and press from the front remained valuable. From our perspective, the ideas were good, execution slightly erratic, hence the middle-of-the-road rating.
Gonzalo Tapia - 9: Tapia was the clear highest rated player on the pitch. A brace in a knockout away tie, plus a won penalty he converted, is huge. We noticed his confidence spike after the early spot-kick goal at 9 minutes; his body language screamed belief. He hit all three shots on target, scored twice, and bullied Miami’s defence in duels. Yes, he picked up a yellow card and missed a big chance, but that’s almost nitpicking. From our perspective, this was a statement performance, the kind that changes a player’s season.
Advertisement
Substitutes
Andre Gomes - 6.5: Coming on for Chambost at 59 minutes, Gomes helped manage the lead. We noticed his positioning more than flashy moments, sitting in pockets and closing passing lanes. With Columbus already 3-0 up, his job was mostly controlling tempo. He kept things simple, which suited the game state. From our perspective, he contributed calmly, even if the numbers don’t jump off the page.
Josef Martínez - 6: Martínez replaced Tapia just after the third goal, inheriting a comfortable scenario. We noticed he focused on pressing and holding the ball rather than chasing more goals. His touches were limited, and he mainly protected possession in advanced areas. In truth, Columbus had shifted to game management mode. A quiet but professional cameo that did not change the narrative much.
Eric Bailly - 6: Bailly came on for Moreira at 71 minutes and slotted into defence. We watched him bring physicality, winning a couple of key duels late on. His passing was straightforward, avoiding risky vertical balls. With Miami pushing desperately, he cleared danger zones when needed. From our perspective, he did exactly what a late defensive sub should do.
Sekou Bangoura - 6: Replacing Santiago Rodríguez at 71 minutes, Bangoura added fresh legs up front. He pressed Miami’s back line and chased lost causes, helping disrupt buildup. However, Columbus focused on solidity, so attacking chances for him were scarce. His movement looked intelligent, even if end product was minimal. We’d call it a steady, hard-working cameo rather than a headline act.
Manager
L. Courtois - 8: From our perspective, Courtois nailed the game plan away from home. Columbus absorbed early pressure, trusted Schulte, then struck clinically through Tapia and Habroune. His response to Miami’s red card felt measured, not overly aggressive, prioritising control over chaos. The substitutions at 59 and 71 minutes showed good understanding of managing legs and emotions. Overall, he out-coached González Peret on the night, and the 3-0 scoreline reflects that.
Advertisement
Inter Miami Player Ratings vs Columbus Crew
Here are the Inter Miami player ratings from the Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew player ratings.
Goalkeeper
Dayne St. Clair - 5.5: St. Clair’s numbers look tidy, but the penalty concession is a killer. His early foul gave Tapia the opening goal, immediately putting Miami behind. We noticed his distribution was actually good, 13 accurate passes and strong long balls. He made two saves inside the box, yet never quite felt dominant. From our perspective, he wasn’t the worst player, but big moments went against him.
Defenders
Gonzalo Luján - 3.5: Luján’s red card completely swung the match. He took two yellows by 36 minutes and left his teammates with ten men. We noticed his early aggression in duels, winning some, but it quickly became reckless. The dismissal forced Miami to change shape and mentality, and they never recovered. His passing was fine, but that doesn’t offset the enormous damage. From our perspective, he was the worst performer in the match.
Casemiro - 6: Casemiro, used as a defender here, had a complicated evening. He completed 53 passes and sprayed nine long balls, trying to launch counters. Defensively, seven won duels and four tackles show real effort. However, we noticed the back line’s organisation crumble after the red card. He looked frustrated, constantly yelling at teammates and chasing spaces that kept opening. From our perspective, he fought hard but couldn’t stabilise the chaos.
Micael - 5.5: Micael’s numbers suggest solid work, yet Columbus targeted his side often. He completed 46 of 50 passes and made three tackles, two won. We noticed him commit three fouls, sometimes out of position and reacting late. His duel success rate hovered below half, allowing Tapia and Brais to exploit channels. He tried stepping out with the ball, but turnovers hurt Miami in transition. Overall, an honest shift that fell short under intense pressure.
Ian Fray - 5.5: Fray had flashes of bravery, especially with dribble attempts from the back. He won five of nine duels and an aerial, showing physical presence. But his 68% pass accuracy really stood out to us in a bad way. Turnovers from deep positions fed Columbus counters directly. The yellow card at 66 minutes summed up his increasingly desperate defending. From our perspective, he never looked fully comfortable against Columbus’ movement.
Advertisement
Midfielders
Rodrigo De Paul - 6.5: De Paul was one of Miami’s better performers despite the scoreline. He completed 59 of 65 passes, used the ball wisely, and created one big chance. We noticed him constantly demanding the ball, trying to drag his team upfield. Defensively, he chipped in with tackles and five ball recoveries. Yet being a man down limited his influence; he ended up chasing shadows at times. From our perspective, he deserved a more flattering result.
Telasco Segovia - 6: Segovia started brightly, with two shots and a blocked effort inside the first half hour. His passing was secure, 26 accurate at 90%, and he tried progressive balls. We noticed him fade as Columbus tightened control, especially after the second goal. Defensively, he struggled in duels and got dribbled past twice. Still, his intent to be positive was clear. From our perspective, he was okay, just overwhelmed by game context.
Yannick Bright - 5: Bright had a wildly mixed evening in midfield. On paper, eight won duels and eight tackles look fantastic. But the key detail is the error leading to a goal, which hurt badly. We noticed his yellow card and three fouls as signs of over-commitment. He seemed emotionally shaken after that mistake, shoulders dropping and intensity turning frantic. Subbed off at 62 minutes, his night ended on a sour note.
Forwards
Luis Suárez - 6: Suárez’s experience showed in flashes early on. He linked play with 10 accurate passes and drew two fouls. His missed big chance, however, felt huge given how tight things were. We noticed his frustration, especially after offside calls and a blocked lane into Messi. Defensively, he tried to help with two tackles, which is rare for him. Subbed at halftime, his impact ended up limited and a little disappointing.
Germán Berterame - 6: Berterame probably should have scored at least once. He had three shots, two on target, and two big chances missed. We noticed his movement was sharp, constantly pulling onto weak shoulders in the box. He also contributed defensively with a tackle and a couple of recoveries. But in knockout football, missing chances hurts more than usual. From our perspective, his performance was brave but wasteful.
Lionel Messi - 7: Messi looked dangerous, but not decisive, which feels strange. He took two shots on target, forced Schulte into good saves, and completed four dribbles. We noticed him dropping deep, almost into midfield, in search of space. His 20 accurate passes and two key passes showed quality on the ball. Yet losing possession 17 times under heavy pressure highlighted his frustration. From our perspective, he was Inter Miami’s main attacking threat, but Columbus contained him well.
Substitutes
Matías Galarza - 6: Galarza entered at halftime for Suárez, trying to add energy and control. We noticed him dropping between lines, attempting to link Messi with deeper midfielders. With Miami behind and down to ten men, his task was almost impossible. Still, he moved the ball with reasonable care and pressed with intent. From our perspective, he offered effort more than genuine transformation.
Alexander Shaw - 6: Shaw replaced Bright at 62 minutes, tasked with steadying midfield. He kept his passing simple, rarely forcing risky balls under Columbus pressure. We noticed him tracking runners diligently, trying to plug gaps around Casemiro and De Paul. However, by then the match tempo had swung toward game management. His cameo was competent but inevitably overshadowed by the earlier damage.
Fricio Caicedo - 5.5: Caicedo’s short outing was hard to judge. He came off for Segovia at 67 minutes, so we mainly recall early touches. He offered some pressing and simple passing without major influence. From our perspective, he felt like a piece in a bigger tactical puzzle. Unfortunately, the red card and goals meant the structure around him collapsed.
Facundo Mura - 6: Mura replaced Fray late, trying to bring fresh defensive legs. He defended bravely in wide areas, chasing Columbus runners. His impact with the ball was minimal, given Miami’s exhausted state. We noticed him urging teammates forward, but the belief seemed gone. A respectable cameo in a difficult situation.
Manager
C. González Peret - 5.5: From our perspective, González Peret’s plan actually looked decent for the first 30 minutes. Miami created chances, pressed high, and Messi saw plenty of the ball. However, the team lost emotional control, culminating in Luján’s red card and multiple bookings. His in-game response to going a man down never fully convinced us; structure looked shaky. The substitutions were logical but felt reactive more than proactive. In the end, he was outmaneuvered by Courtois in this MLS Cup tie.
Also Read

Real Madrid vs Celta Vigo Player Ratings: Jude Bellingham 9.1/10 as Los Blancos Came From Behind to Win At The Bernabeu
Real Madrid vs Celta Vigo player ratings: MOTM Bellingham earns 9.1/10 in a 2-2 draw, while Javi Rodriguez's 5.5/10 conceding a penalty and is the lowest for Celta Vigo.
15 min
12h ago
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the result of Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
+
What was the result of Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew finished 3-0 to Columbus Crew, a dominant away victory.
When was Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
+
When was Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew was played on November 21, 2026, in Major League Soccer.
Who was the man of the match in Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
+
Who was the man of the match in Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
In Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew, Gonzalo Tapia was widely regarded as man of the match.
Who was the worst performer in Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
+
Who was the worst performer in Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew?
In Inter Miami vs Columbus Crew, Gonzalo Luján was the worst performer after his costly red card.
Conversation
(0 Comments)
Editor's Pick
Editor's Pick









-1754988285871.webp)
