Man United Vs Newcastle United Player Ratings as Dorgu's Goal Pushes United Into Top 5

A first-half strike from Patrick Dorgu was enough for Manchester United to clinch a narrow 1-0 victory over Newcastle United in a tense Premier League clash at Old Trafford. It was a game of fine margins, a real nail-biter that could have swung either way.

Both teams rattled the woodwork in the second half, with striker Benjamin Sesko for the hosts and Lewis Hall for the visitors coming agonizingly close. It felt like one of those games where the next goal would be decisive, but it never came. Instead, defenses largely came out on top in a gritty, hard-fought contest.

The decisive moment arrived in the 24th minute, a well-taken goal that ultimately separated the two sides in this match. While Newcastle United pushed hard for an equalizer, creating several golden opportunities, a combination of strong defending and some crucial saves ensured the Red Devils held on for a vital win. It was a victory built on grit rather than glamour.

Here are the Man United Vs Newcastle United Player Ratings

Man United Player Ratings vs Newcastle United

Here are Man United Player Ratings vs Newcastle United

Goalkeeper

Senne Lammens - 7.5: We noticed his confidence from the start. He commanded his box well, making two excellent high claims. Lammens made a few critical saves, especially the one to deny Joelinton late in the game, which preserved the win. His distribution was a little shaky, but when it mattered, he was a solid wall for his team.

Defenders

Diogo Dalot - 7.0: A really solid defensive showing from Dalot. He was in the right place at the right time with seven clearances and two crucial blocked shots. However, he missed a massive chance to seal the game, which was frustrating to watch. He did his main job well, but that missed opportunity sticks in the mind.

Lisandro Martínez - 7.5: He wore the captain's armband with pride. Martínez was a rock at the back, organizing the defense and showing his usual tenacity with a crucial interception and seven clearances. He even created a big chance for his team. His departure due to injury was a major concern, as he was leading by example throughout.

Luke Shaw - 7.0: A typical Luke Shaw performance. He was defensively sound, winning most of his duels and making some important interceptions. What stood out to us was his reading of the game. He picked up a yellow card for a cynical foul, but it was one he probably had to make. A dependable display before he was substituted.

Ayden Heaven - 7.0: For a player thrown into the mix, Heaven looked incredibly composed. His pass accuracy of 94% was outstanding, and he wasn't afraid to get stuck in. He made eight clearances and never looked flustered. It was a performance that defied his experience, and he showed he belongs at this level.

Midfielders

Casemiro - 6.0: A mixed bag from the Brazilian. He missed a sitter early on that he really should have buried. While he was tidy in possession with 91% pass accuracy, he seemed a bit off the pace and was dribbled past. He did his defensive work but didn't dominate the midfield as we know he can before being subbed off.

Manuel Ugarte - 7.0: The engine in midfield. Ugarte was everywhere, winning eight duels and making six tackles which was just relentless. He was a disruptive force for Newcastle's midfield. However, he did lose the ball a few times in dangerous areas, but his energy and aggression were vital to breaking up play.

Mason Mount - 5.5: A really disappointing first half from Mount. He just couldn't get into the game and was hooked at halftime. His 64% pass accuracy tells its own story. He lost possession 11 times from only 28 touches which is just not good enough. It felt like the game was passing him by completely.

Matheus Cunha - 6.5: A very frustrating afternoon for Cunha. He was a constant threat with his dribbling and forced a good save from the keeper. But he was also wasteful, losing possession frequently and picking up a needless yellow card late on. He has the talent, but his decision-making let him down today.

Forwards

Patrick Dorgu - 8.5: The clear man of the match. He took his goal with the composure of a seasoned striker. Beyond the goal, he was a menace, forcing another save and contributing defensively with eight duels won. From our perspective, he was the difference-maker and fully deserved his moment of glory.

Benjamin Sesko - 6.0: It just wasn't his day. He was desperately unlucky to see his powerful shot cannon back off the crossbar. Sesko got into good positions but missed a couple of chances he'd expect to score. His link-up play was decent, but a striker is judged on goals, and he drew a blank.

Substitutes

Jack Fletcher - 6.5: Came on for Mount and brought more stability to the midfield. Kept it simple and tidy.
Joshua Zirkzee - 6.0: Replaced Sesko but didn't offer a significantly greater threat.
Leny Yoro - 6.5: Slotted in for Casemiro and helped shore things up defensively.
Tyrell Malacia - N/A: Not on long enough to rate.
Tyler Fredricson - N/A: Came on late to see out the win.

Manager

R. Amorim - 7.0: A win is a win. His team was organized and resilient, even if they weren't spectacular. He got the crucial goal and then managed the game effectively, using his substitutions to counter injuries and protect the lead. It was a pragmatic victory, and he'll be delighted with the three points.

Newcastle United Player Ratings vs Man United

Here are Newcastle United Player Ratings vs Man United

Goalkeeper

Aaron Ramsdale - 6.5: He couldn't do much about Dorgu's clinical finish. Ramsdale made a couple of important saves to keep his team in the contest. Overall, it was a relatively quiet day for him, which is ironic given his team lost. He did what was asked of him.

Defenders

Lewis Hall - 8.0: An outstanding performance from Hall. He was Newcastle's best player by a country mile, a constant threat down the left flank. He was so unlucky to hit the woodwork and won an incredible 13 duels. He was a one-man army at times, defending with tenacity and attacking with purpose. A superb display.

Fabian Schär - 6.5: A solid enough game from the Swiss defender. He was strong in the air, winning four aerial duels. However, an error that led to a shot blemished his copybook. He was composed on the ball but had a few moments that would have had his manager's heart in his mouth.

Malick Thiaw - 7.0: We were very impressed by Thiaw. He was excellent in possession, boasting a 92% pass accuracy, and read the game brilliantly to recover the ball nine times. He was calm, collected, and snuffed out several United attacks before they could develop. A very strong showing.

Lewis Miley - 7.0: Played in a more defensive role and looked right at home. He had more touches than almost anyone and his 95% pass accuracy was phenomenal. He kept possession ticking over and was a calming influence on the ball. He didn't offer a huge attacking threat but was incredibly reliable.

Midfielders

Bruno Guimarães - 6.5: The captain was on the ball constantly, trying to dictate play. He had over 100 touches and kept probing the United defense. However, he struggled to provide that killer pass to unlock the home defense. A busy but ultimately frustrating afternoon for him.

Sandro Tonali - 6.5: A typically industrious performance from the Italian. He worked tirelessly, won his tackles, and delivered some dangerous crosses. He picked up a yellow card for his troubles and was a bit loose in possession at times. A solid, if unspectacular, shift before being subbed.

Jacob Ramsey - 6.0: A very quiet game from Ramsey. While he was tidy on the ball, he offered very little in an attacking sense and failed to make an impact. From our perspective, he seemed to be a passenger for large parts of the game before his substitution.

Forwards

Anthony Gordon - 6.5: He looked like Newcastle's most likely source of a goal. Gordon created three chances but was also guilty of missing a big one himself. His final ball was inconsistent, with only two of his ten crosses finding a teammate. A lively but inefficient performance.

Jacob Murphy - 6.0: Murphy was a willing runner and put in a lot of crosses, but the quality was severely lacking. Only one of his eleven crosses was successful. He worked hard for the team but didn't provide the cutting edge needed in the final third.

Nick Woltemade - 5.0: A day to forget for the forward. He was completely anonymous. With only 26 touches in 68 minutes, he was a ghost. He lost possession 14 times and struggled to get involved in any meaningful way. It was a surprise he stayed on the pitch as long as he did.

Substitutes

Joelinton - 7.0: Made a real impact after coming on, forcing a good save and adding a physical presence.
Yoane Wissa - 6.5: Looked lively and created a chance for a teammate.
Harvey Barnes - 6.0: Didn't see much of the ball to make a difference.
Joe Willock - N/A: Not on long enough to rate.

Manager

E. Howe - 6.5: His team will feel incredibly unlucky not to get something from this match. They created good chances and hit the bar. However, his initial selection of Woltemade was a mistake, as the forward offered nothing. His substitutions improved the team, but it was a case of too little, too late.

Sportsdunia's player of the match is Dorgu