Everton Transfer Analysis and Overview – 2024
Everton Football Club is one of the oldest and proudest teams in English football and was one of the founding members of both the Football League and Premier League. With twenty-four major trophies in their trophy collection including nine English League titles and five FA Cups, the club has been carrying the sigil of a rich footballing history of England.
The Toffees finished in the 15th spot in the 2023/24 English Premier League which forced their hands to offload some of the notable players from their squad in order to vacate space for potential newcomers. However, despite making significant signings in the summer transfer window of the 2024/25 season, their fate has not seen much outward road with a journey of high and low. But, it has not changed the structure of their plan in the transfer market which has been full of some strange buys and sales. With a long insightful history, Everton Football Club, which is also called “The Toffees or The People’s Club”, has been one of the most successful clubs in the transfer market, in both players, sales, and buys.
Everton Transfers Club Performance History
Everton Football Club have had a graceful journey in the transfer market since the first day of Football League. In the inaugural season of the English Premier League in 1992, the Toffees had a net expenditure of £5.4 million which saw them lure in seven players including the great forward Paul Rideout who came from Rangers. Since then, more than 2000 players have been traded by the Merseyside outfit in the transfer market.
Players like Romelu Lukaku, Mikel Arteta, Peter Reid, and Tim Cahill have been brought into Goodison Park which have influenced the course of history for Everton, demonstrating the club’s successful vision to find great talents in the transfer market. Despite being bound by their financial limitations, the Liverpool-based club have signed high-profile players Jake O’Brien and Iliman Ndiaye in the 2024 summer transfer window. Despite many players failing to impress after coming to the club, it is fair to say that Everton holds an aura of great performance in its transfer strategy so far.
Everton Transfer Strategy and Philosophy
Everton’s transfer strategy has always boasted the club’s ambitions in buying world-class talents from different leagues. However, the recent financial constraints have seen a shift in the club’s approach to the 2024 summer transfer window.
The Premier League club’s priorities have always been finding not-so-popular players in the market and bringing those young talents to the youth academy. Everton’s 20024/25 summer transfer deals have hinted at a possible strategic foresight of the club management that will shape the trajectory of their 2025 January transfer window. The club has always seeked to bolster its youth academy, which has always been a crucial supply line of talents. Now, with Everton shifting their focus to asset management, they are expected to avoid the pitfalls of past lavish spending that led to economic woes.
Everton Transfer 2024 Challenges & Criticisms
The one and only challenge Everton face in 2024 is the club’s financial crunch, owing to their new stadium at Bramley Moore Dock. The estimated cost to build the new facility which is under construction and is expected to be ready by 2025, is around £786 million. As a result, the decision-making process in transfers has been centralised, with the director of football Kevin Delwell at the helm of the process.
Toffees were on a spending spree in recent years, resulting in some devastating failures which have drawn wide-ranging criticism from the fans of the club. The decision making in the 2023-24 transfer market was done by a wider group of people, but this time things have changed as Everton are expected to be in the transfer business influenced by the ideas and inputs of manager Sean Dyche and the head of the recruitment team, Dan Prudy.
Most Expensive Everton Transfers
Everton FC have always been a lavish spender in the transfer market. Most of the club’s big spending have been executed in the last decade after Farhad Moshiri took over the majority stake in 2016. Despite him splashing the cash, the results have remained ineffective. The Premier League club have slowed down their approach of going after players with big price tags recently after performing poorly in the transfer market. But, they still remain one of the major English clubs who have made some expensive transfers over the years. On that note, let’s take a look at the most expensive Everton transfers of all-time.
| Player | Transfer fee | Club (from) | Year |
| Gylfi Sigurdsson | £42.6 million | Swansea | 2017 |
| Amadou Onana | £34.4 million | Lille | 2022 |
| Richarlison | £33.8 million | Watford | 2018 |
| Romelu Lukaku | £30.5 million | Chelsea | 2014 |
Everton Transfers New Signings 2024/25
Everton Football Club are currently operating at a loss, but the tradition of signing new players to strengthen the squad in search of a top-four finish in the 2024/25 English Premier League has stayed intact. After witnessing a lackluster performance in defense, Sean Dyche has brought in the Ligue 1 center-back Jack O’Brien from Lyon on a £15.2 million transfer deal. The in-form left-winger Iliman Ndiaye has also been signed for £14.2 million to bolster the attack that has been wasteful in the last season.
| Player | Transfer fee | Club (from) |
| Jack O’Brien | £15.2 million | Lyon |
| Iliman Ndiaye | £14.2 million | Marseille |
| Tim Iroegbunam | £8.5 million | Aston Villa |
| Jasper Lindstrom | £1.6 million | Napoli (on loan) |
Everton Transfers All Outgoing 2024/2025
Financial worries have brought a restraining order in Everton’s transfer strategy of late. The Merseyside club have been forced to sell some of the promising players who were pivotal in their journey in the Premier League for the last couple of years. The transfer of Amadou Onana to Aston Villa in 2024 was reportedly a part of the plan to bring in cash to tackle the financial instability at the club. The Toffees earned £47.5 million in their former midfielder’s sale. Along with Onana, seven more players have been offloaded in the 2024/25 summer transfer window.
| Player | Transfer fee | Club (to) |
| Amadou Onana | £47.5 million | Aston Villa |
| Ben Godfrey | £9.6 million | Atalanta |
| Lewis Dobbin | £9.4 million | Aston Villa |
| Neal Maupay | £400,000 | Marseille (on loan) |
Top Signings for Everton in 2024-25
Everton Football Club have opted for a cautious approach in the 2024/25 transfer market as they are running at a loss and are in need of a substantial amount of money to back their stadium construction project. But, amidst this tough time, the Liverpool-based outfit has made some calculated signings in the 2024 summer transfer window to reinforce some areas. Among all arrivals, the most notable one is their new defender Jack O’Brien, who arrived from Lyon on a £15.2 million contract. He has not played many games for the Toffees, but he has shown glimpses of his high potential.
Worst Signings for Everton in 2024-25
Everton brought in new players in the summer transfer window in 2024, and it has been five months since then. It is too early to predict the worst signings for Everton this season. However, Tim Iroegbunam is yet to find his rhythm under Sean Dyche. The English midfielder has made six Premier League appearances this season with no performance to justify potential so far.
Everton Transfer Spend Till Now
Everton is one of the biggest spenders in the English Premier League as the club broke the bank last decade for a string of signings in the transfer market. Sitting at an estimated value of £810 million as of 2024, the Merseyside club is now facing financial issues on all fronts. Under Farhad Moshiri, they have had an expenditure worth £680 million in transfers. In players’ sales, the Toffees have earned around £530 million since 2016.
| Total Spend (in 2024) | Total Received (in 2024) |
| £40 million | £66 million |
