Who are 5 Best FPL Captains to Pick in GW 4?

Gameweek 4 is more than a week away, and if you’re like most managers, you’re probably already stressing about your FPL captain picks. That little armband decision can make or break your week, and we all know the difference between a green arrow and a red one often comes down to who to captain FPL. With some mouthwatering fixtures on the horizon, this feels like one of those weeks where several options look appealing.
So, let’s dive in and break down the five best FPL captain choices for Gameweek 4, with a mix of the obvious big hitters and a couple of cheeky differentials that could give your team the edge. For more tips, check out our FPL cheat sheet for GW 4.

Top 5 Captaincy Choice for Gameweek 4

Mohamed Salah (Burnley vs Liverpool)

When there’s ever a question about the FPL captain this week, Mohamed Salah always finds his way into the conversation. Facing Burnley away might look tricky on paper, but let’s be honest, Salah has been one of the most reliable fantasy scorers for years, and the man loves to punish teams that try to keep things tight at the back.
Burnley’s defence hasn’t exactly looked watertight so far this season, and they tend to leave a bit of space between the lines. That’s exactly where Salah thrives. His underlying stats are still elite, plenty of shots in the box, high expected goals (xG), and involvement in nearly everything Liverpool create going forward, making him one of the best midfielders for gameweek 4.
On top of that, he’s likely on penalties, which just adds to his appeal as a safe, reliable captaincy option. If you’re the type of manager who doesn’t like to gamble too much and just wants steady points from your FPL captain, Salah is your guy this Gameweek.

Joao Pedro (Brentford vs Chelsea)

Now here’s an interesting name, Joao Pedro against Brentford. When most people are asking themselves who to captain FPL, not many will immediately think of Pedro, but maybe they should.
First, Brentford’s defence has looked pretty shaky. They keep making sloppy errors and conceding goals that could’ve been avoided. Pedro, on the other hand, has been quietly racking up attacking returns, and his role in this Chelsea side is becoming more central with every game.
What makes him particularly appealing is that he’s not just a goal-scorer; he’s creative too. Pedro often drifts into spaces between midfield and defence, which Brentford have struggled to deal with. He’s also been on penalty duties at times, which is always a bonus when considering FPL captain picks.
Now, let’s be clear, captaining Joao Pedro is definitely more of a differential pick. He doesn’t offer the same security as Salah or Haaland, but if you’re chasing rank early or just fancy a gamble, he could really explode this week.

Erling Haaland (Manchester City vs Manchester United)

It feels almost criminal to have Haaland third on this list, but that’s more to do with the fixture than the player himself. The Manchester Derby usually isn’t the kind of fixture where captaincy points flow freely… but then again, Haaland has shown he doesn’t really care about fixtures.
He’s the ultimate FPL machine, tons of shots, relentless movement, and always in the right place to finish City’s endless stream of chances. Yes, United may try to tighten up defensively and make the game scrappy, but can anyone really stop Haaland when he’s in the mood?
For many managers, slapping the armband on Haaland is the default move. It’s safe, it’s boring, but it works. If he hauls and you don’t captain him, the pain is brutal. That’s why he will probably be the most popular FPL captain this week, no matter the fixture.
So the real question is: do you want to play it safe, or do you back yourself to outsmart the crowd?

Enzo Fernandes (Brentford vs Chelsea)

Now let’s talk about a slightly unexpected candidate, Enzo Fernandes. He’s not the first name that comes to mind when you think FPL captain picks, but hear us out.
This season, Enzo has been given a more advanced midfield role under Chelsea’s new structure, and he’s starting to show exactly why he was brought in for a massive fee. He’s influencing play higher up the pitch, getting into attacking positions, and he’s even had some set-piece involvement.
Against Brentford, Chelsea will need control in midfield, and Enzo could be the one pulling strings. He’s not as explosive as Salah or Haaland, but if you’re one of those managers who loves trying out unique captaincy punts, Enzo could be an interesting shout.
Of course, this is a risky pick; nobody will be surprised if Enzo returns just a couple of appearance points. But just imagine the glory (and bragging rights) if you hit gold with this call while everyone else goes boring with the template picks.

Antoine Semenyo (Bournemouth vs Brighton)

Here’s the wildcard pick of the lot, Antoine Semenyo. Yes, you read that right! Bournemouth’s main man has shown flashes of brilliance this season, and with Brighton’s defence looking extremely leaky, there’s potential for him to exploit the space left behind when they push forward.
Semenyo’s appeal comes from his directness. He loves running at defenders, taking on shots from distance, and getting into goal-scoring positions, which is why he's one of the players whose FPL price has risen. Brighton’s style of play always leaves them wide open on transitions, which is exactly where Semenyo thrives.
Now, let’s be real, captaining Semenyo this week is not for the faint-hearted. He’s more of a high-risk, high-reward shout. But if you’re chasing early rank or you just love being bold with your picks, he might be the cheeky captaincy punt who brings you unexpected success.

Who Should Be Your FPL Captain This Week?

When it comes down to it, the captaincy choice for Gameweek 4 depends on your risk appetite.

• Safe & reliable: Salah versus Burnley is probably the best mix of fixture and form.
• Popular & safe (fear of missing out pick): Haaland, because even if he fails to score, so many managers will captain him that you won’t fall behind.
• Differential punts: Joao Pedro, Enzo Fernandes, and Semenyo are the wildcard choices. They’re less steady, but the upside is huge if they deliver and the main players blank.

If you’re leading in your mini-league and want to play it safe, Salah or Haaland is the way to go. But if you’re trying to climb the ranks, this could be the week to roll the dice with a surprising name.