Everton vs Man United Lineups Today: Is this Michael Carrick's Best Starting XI for Everton?

The wait is over. Everton vs Man United lineups have officially been revealed ahead of this crucial Premier League clash at Hill Dickinson Stadium, and there are some big talking points. With suspensions, tactical adjustments, and key selection decisions shaping both sides, tonight’s starting XIs could significantly influence how this encounter unfolds. Supporters were eager to see how each manager would respond to recent form and availability concerns.

Now, with kickoff approaching, the confirmed teams provide a clear insight into the tactical battle about to begin. The Everton vs Man United lineups confirm important changes in defense and attack that could define this Premier League fixture.

Everton Starting XI vs Man United

Everton’s lineup today reflects defensive reshuffling, particularly following Jake O’Brien’s suspension after his red card in the previous match against Bournemouth. His absence forces structural adjustments at the back. For a full breakdown, read our analysis on why is Jake O’Brien not playing vs Manchester United. The English defensive midfielder, James Garner, is replacing him.

The midfield selection suggests intensity and pressing with Idrissa Gueye and Iroegbunam, and they will likely aim at disrupting Manchester United’s rhythm early on. In attack, Everton appears set to rely on movement and width rather than a direct aerial approach, hinting at a flexible game plan. However, the club will need their striker, Thierno Barry, to find his form as he hasn't scored a single goal in the last 3 matches.

Confirmed: Everton Lineup vs Man United (4-2-3-1)

Jordan Pickford (GK); James Garner, Michael Keane, James Tarkowski, Jarrad Branthwaite; Tim Iroegbunam, Idrissa Gana Gueye; Iliman Ndiaye, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Harrison Armstrong; Thierno Barry

Man United Starting XI vs Everton

Manchester United’s lineup today highlights their confidence as they have made just one change, with Leny Yoro replacing Lisandro Martinez at the back. The defensive line looks stable with all players looking calm and confident, while the midfield combination signals balance, control, and creativity with Mainoo, Casemiro, and Bruno.

The only notable attacking selection from Michael Carrick suggests a preference for physical presence and structured build-up play in the early phases of the match. At the same time, pace out wide remains a key weapon, particularly in counter-attacking moments. Importantly, bench options provide flexibility if the match demands greater creativity or tempo in the second half.

Confirmed: Man United Lineup vs Everton (4-2-3-1)

Senne Lammens (GK); Diogo Dalot, Harry Maguire, Leny Yoro, Luke Shaw; Casemiro, Kobbie Mainoo; Amad, Bruno Fernandes, Bryan Mbeumo; Matheus Cunha

Why These Lineups Matter Tonight

Fixtures between these two English football teams are often decided in midfield battles and counter scenarios. With both managers making purposeful calls, the tactical chess match is already underway before the first whistle. However, if you are a fan who would like to closely and more deeply follow this rivalry, do check out our head-to-head Everton vs Man United.

With Chelsea and Aston Villa dropping points in this gameweek, the Red Devils have a chance to solidify their position in the top 4. Though even a draw will suffice, they will prefer to go home with 3 points nonetheless. Meanwhile, the Toffees have a chance to move up in the table; however, to do that, they will need to stop the in-form Carrick-led Manchester United.

Everton can exploit the 20-time Premier League winners' struggle against low blocks, as evident during the West Ham draw. While Man United will look to pile pressure on their opponents during set-pieces, as they are struggling to defend.