Aston Villa 1-3 Newcastle United Player Ratings: Magpies Pull Off Second-Half Comeback Against 10-Man Hosts

Villa Park played host to a dramatic FA Cup fixture as Aston Villa lost control against Newcastle United after the hosts went down to ten men. As the Magpies won the crucial game 3-1, let's discuss Aston Villa vs Newcastle United player ratings from the match.

Villa made a strong start and were on top in the opening period. They moved the ball well and created chances. The breakthrough came when Tammy Abraham scored to give the home side the lead. Villa looked settled and in charge, with the crowd fully behind them.

The turning point came just before half-time. Goalkeeper Marco Bizot was sent off after a poor decision outside his box. The red card changed the direction of the match.

Newcastle took control after the break. With the extra man, they pressed higher and played with confidence. Sandro Tonali was central to their comeback, controlling the midfield and driving his side forward.

Villa struggled to cope in the second half. Newcastle made the most of their advantage and took charge of the game.

Key Takeaways

• Tammy Abraham opened the scoring to give Aston Villa an early lead.
• Goalkeeper Marco Bizot was sent off just before half-time, leaving Villa with ten men.
• Sandro Tonali led Newcastle United in the second half, taking control and securing a 3-1 win.

Aston Villa Player Ratings vs Newcastle United

Check out Aston Villa player ratings from the FA Cup match against Newcastle United:

Goalkeeper

Marco Bizot - 3.0: What can you even say? He was having a quiet game until his moment of sheer panic. The red card was absolutely deserved and it cost his team the entire match. He let everyone down with a reckless foul. A catastrophic error that he will want to forget very quickly.

Defenders

Victor Lindelöf - 6.5: We noticed he was fighting a losing battle. He made six clearances and a couple of crucial blocked shots. Despite conceding three goals, he individually didn't do too much wrong. He was simply overwhelmed by the constant pressure in the second half.

Lucas Digne - 6.0: A really mixed performance from the captain. He created an impressive four chances and his delivery was often dangerous. However, he picked up a silly yellow card and was part of a defensive unit that crumbled. He needed to show more leadership when the tide turned.

Pau Torres - 5.5: He was incredibly busy, as his nine clearances suggest. But he looked shaky under pressure and was often reactive rather than proactive. From our perspective, he struggled to cope with Newcastle's renewed attacking vigor and was caught out of position a few times. A difficult evening for the Spaniard.

Lamare Bogarde - 4.5: A night to forget for the youngster. An error leading to a goal is a defender's worst nightmare. He looked off the pace and struggled with the intensity of the game. It was a harsh lesson for him at this level.

Midfielders

Ross Barkley - 5.5: Had a bright moment with a shot on target that was well saved. But beyond that, he was largely anonymous before being substituted. He failed to grab the game by the scruff of the neck when his team needed some control in midfield.

Douglas Luiz - 6.5: Provided a lovely assist for Abraham's goal and looked sharp early on. The early yellow card seemed to temper his aggression, though. After the red card, he was fighting a losing battle in the middle of the park. He tried his best under impossible circumstances.

Amadou Onana - 7.0: A real warrior in a defeated army. What stood out to us was his sheer desire, winning an incredible 12 duels. He was a colossal presence physically and never shied away from a challenge. One of the few Villa players who can hold their head high.

Morgan Rogers - 5.5: Full of running and effort, but the quality wasn't there. He lost possession far too often and his final ball was lacking. He worked hard for the team, but it just wasn't his night from an attacking standpoint.

Leon Bailey - 6.0: Looked dangerous and lively in the first half. He was the unfortunate sacrificial lamb, substituted after the keeper's red card. It was a shame because he seemed like he could have caused Newcastle real problems. He did miss one big chance, however.

Forwards

Tammy Abraham - 7.5: He was excellent before his substitution. He took his goal well and was a constant handful for the Newcastle defenders. His hold-up play was strong, and it was a blow for Villa when he had to go off. A very positive performance.

Substitutes

Emiliano Martínez - 6.0: Came into an impossible situation. Conceded three goals but couldn't have done much about any of them. Made the saves he was expected to make.

Ollie Watkins - 5.5: Thrown on to chase the game but was completely isolated upfront. He barely had a touch of the ball as Newcastle dominated possession.

Emiliano Buendía - 5.5: Tried to make things happen but found himself crowded out by a compact Newcastle midfield.

Ian Maatsen & Jadon Sancho - N/A: Came on too late to have any meaningful impact on the result.

Manager

U. Emery Etxegoien - 6.0: His game plan was working perfectly for 45 minutes. The team was structured, disciplined, and carried a threat. His goalkeeper's moment of madness destroyed his strategy, and there was little he could do to salvage the game with ten men.

Newcastle United Player Ratings vs Aston Villa

Here are Newcastle United player ratings from the game:

Goalkeeper

Aaron Ramsdale - 6.5: Had one significant save to make from Barkley in the first half and he did it well. He was beaten by Abraham's goal but was otherwise untroubled. A steady, if quiet, performance from the keeper.

Defenders

Kieran Trippier - 7.5: A captain's performance. Defensively solid, winning most of his duels, and a constant threat going forward. He created three chances and his delivery from the right was superb. A class act.

Lewis Hall - 6.5: A neat and tidy game. He was secure in possession and didn't take any unnecessary risks. Didn't offer a huge amount in an attacking sense but fulfilled his defensive duties diligently. A solid, if unspectacular, outing.

Malick Thiaw - 7.5: What a rock at the back. We noticed him making three huge blocks and he was dominant in the air. His distribution was also top-notch, with a 91% pass accuracy. He was composed and authoritative throughout the match.

Dan Burn - 7.0: Provided the assist for Tonali's crucial second goal. He used his physicality to dominate his flank. While a bit clumsy at times, his overall contribution was hugely positive for the team.

Midfielders

Sandro Tonali - 9.0: Absolutely sensational. The undisputed Man of the Match. His two goals were sublime strikes from distance that changed the game entirely. He ran the show in the second half, dictating the tempo and displaying his incredible technique. The highest-rated player on the pitch by a mile.

Harvey Barnes - 5.5: A frustrating performance to watch. He got into so many good positions but his finishing was woeful. He had five shots and even hit the woodwork. On another day he could have had a hat-trick, but tonight he was wasteful.

Nick Woltemade - 8.0: An all-action display capped with a well-deserved goal. He was a machine in midfield, winning 11 duels and never stopping running. His goal was the icing on the cake for a performance full of grit, determination, and quality. Hugely impressive.

Jacob Ramsey - 5.5: A very quiet game from him. He picked up a yellow card and never really managed to impose himself on the proceedings. He seemed to be a passenger while others around him stepped up. Disappointing.

Forwards

William Osula - 5.0: Struggled to get involved in the game. He had one half-chance that he missed and was largely ineffective before being substituted. A tough night where he couldn't make his mark.

Jacob Murphy - 5.0: His main contribution was being caught offside three times. He failed to provide any real threat down the wing and was rightly substituted. A forgettable performance.

Substitutes

Anthony Gordon - 6.5: Looked sharp and dangerous after coming on, immediately putting the Villa defence on the back foot.

Anthony Elanga - 6.5: Provided a spark of creativity and set up a great chance for Trippier.

Joe Willock & Alex Murphy - N/A: Brought on to see out a comfortable victory and did their jobs without fuss.

Manager

E. Howe - 8.0: He deserves immense credit. His team didn't panic after going a goal down. He set them up perfectly to exploit the one-man advantage in the second half, and his tactical adjustments paid off handsomely. A well-earned and intelligently managed win.

Man of the Match

Sportsdunia's player of the match was Sandro Tonali after registering two goals for Newcastle.

Worst Performer

Marco Bizot saw a red card at the end of the first half, which turned out to be vital.