- Aston Villa had 17 shots in this game with a possession of 73%, but failed to find the back of the net.
- Sunderland had just one shot on target in the entire game and defended their hearts out to take a point back home.
- Unai Emery's side are now winless in their last five games across all competitions.
Advertisement
Aston Villa 0-0 Sunderland Player Ratings: Spoils Shared At The Villa Park As Unai Emery's Side Continue Their Winless Streak

Summary
The Aston Villa vs Sunderland game ended 0-0, with neither side being too satisfied with the final result. Both sides fought for every inch at Villa Park, yet neither could land that decisive punch. The score stayed level, but the rhythm and physical edge of the game kept it compelling throughout.
Aston Villa controlled territory and possession for long stretches, while Sunderland leaned heavily on transitions and defensive resilience. The shot map tells the story, with Villa testing Robin Roefs several times and Sunderland relying on half-chances from distance. In a match of fine margins, the goalkeepers and centre-backs dictated the tone.
What stood out to us most was the sheer volume of niggly fouls and set-piece situations. Leon Goretzka, Trai Hume, and Ian Maatsen all picked up bookings, which mirrored the tense energy on the pitch.
Across the 90 minutes, the structure of this Premier League clash felt solid but occasionally cagey, with both coaches seemingly more afraid of losing than obsessed with winning.
Learn the Aston Villa vs Sunderland Player Ratings here.
Sunderland Player Ratings vs Aston Villa
See the Sunderland Player Ratings from the Aston Villa vs Sunderland Player Ratings.
Goalkeeper
Robin Roefs - 8: For us, Roefs was clearly Sunderland’s standout performer and arguably the highest rated player on the pitch. He produced four important saves, including sharp stops from Emiliano Buendía and Ian Maatsen. His handling looked assured, and that one high claim eased pressure at a crucial moment. We noticed how calm he stayed even as Villa ramped up the tempo. Twelve ball recoveries underline how proactive he was sweeping behind the line. His long passing was a bit erratic, but his shot-stopping fully justified this high rating.
Defenders
Thomas Meunier - 6.5: Meunier had an uneven but honest display from our perspective. He contributed with two clearances, some solid aerial defending, and one key tackle. On the ball he attempted 22 passes and found the final third a few times. However, nine instances of possession lost and a couple of fouls showed his struggles under Villa’s press. We noticed him hesitating in advanced areas, almost overthinking crossing decisions. A decent defensive shift, but not enough thrust going forward to push his rating higher.
Luke O'Nien - 6.5: As captain, O'Nien brought composure and voice to a stretched back line. He used the ball fairly well, with 23 accurate passes and some calm recycling. His three long balls helped Sunderland escape pressure, and defensively he chipped in with two clearances. From our perspective his positioning was generally sound, rarely caught too high. Still, seven turnovers and limited influence in attack kept him from really grabbing the game. A steady, workmanlike outing rather than a commanding one.
Reinildo Mandava - 7: Mandava’s physical presence on the left stood out to us. He made three clearances, one interception, and a clean tackle, rarely getting beaten one‑v‑one. Going forward he chipped in with a key pass and helped set up Enzo Le Fée’s second-half effort. His fouls early on were clumsy, but he settled as the match matured. Fifty percent duels won shows he held his own in tight battles. Overall, his balance of aggression and discipline justified a strong rating.
Nordi Mukiele - 7.5: Mukiele quietly delivered one of Sunderland’s best defensive performances. We noticed how often he stepped in front of Villa attackers, winning six out of seven duels. Five clearances, two interceptions, and a blocked shot highlighted his reading of danger. On the ball he remained tidy with 18 accurate passes and some progressive long balls. There were minor lapses in tackling efficiency, but nothing that truly cost his team. For us, his authority at the back was crucial in preserving the clean sheet.
Advertisement
Midfielders
Chemsdine Talbi - 6: Talbi struggled to impose himself for long stretches. With only 20 touches and 12 passes, he drifted out of the game at times. We noticed his offside call early on, which summed up his slightly rushed attacking movements. Defensively he chipped in with one tackle and a couple of recoveries. However, seven instances of possession lost and limited creativity dragged his influence down. From our perspective, he worked hard but lacked conviction in the final decisions.
Noah Sadiki - 6.5: Sadiki played an understated but useful role in the engine room. He kept the ball moving with 90% passing accuracy, rarely forcing risky options. His one key pass and chance created gave Sunderland a flicker of attacking spark. Defensively he added an interception and three recoveries, though he did give away a foul. What stood out to us was his composure under Villa’s press, even when isolated. Still, he didn’t dominate, and some duels lost limited his overall impact.
Enzo Le Fée - 7: Le Fée was Sunderland’s main creative outlet, even in a scrappy match. He attempted 31 passes with strong accuracy and constantly looked to hit the final third. Two shots, including the late effort saved by Zion Suzuki, showed his ambition. We noticed his energy in pressing and recovering, with six ball recoveries and two tackles won. At times he overcomplicated things, losing possession and even making one error leading to a shot. Still, his influence and bravery on the ball deserve a positive rating.
Jules Ahoka - 6.5: Ahoka had a very mixed afternoon. Five interceptions and four fouls won underline his defensive bite. He also ventured forward with one shot blocked and occasional driving runs. Yet he lost more duels than he won and committed a foul that slowed Sunderland’s momentum. From our perspective, his body language swung between confident and frustrated. The work rate was strong, but decision-making wasn’t always sharp enough.
Trai Hume - 6: Hume’s performance felt edgy from start to finish. He committed several fouls and received a yellow card, which visibly changed his aggression level. Defensively, two tackles won and two clearances showed he still contributed. On the ball he played only seven passes, often opting long rather than building patiently. We noticed him battling hard in duels, winning a fair share despite some late fatigue. Overall, the discipline issues and limited composure kept his rating modest.
Forwards
Wilson Isidor - 5.5: From our perspective, Isidor was Sunderland’s weakest starter. He fought plenty of aerial and ground duels but won very few. His single shot was blocked, and he frequently conceded fouls that relieved Villa’s pressure. Multiple offsides reflected poor timing of runs and perhaps nerves. We noticed his frustration growing as duels slipped away, leading to more rash challenges. Despite honest effort, his lack of end product and constant turnovers justify a low rating.
Advertisement
Substitutes
Nilson Angulo - 6: Angulo entered late and tried to stretch the Villa back line. His offside call, shortly after coming on, showed eagerness but also impatience. We saw him press with intent, even if he didn’t get many touches. One foul conceded highlighted his combative nature. With limited time, he couldn’t truly change the pattern of the game. A neutral impact overall, with promise but no decisive moment.
Manager
R. Le Bris - 6.5: Le Bris clearly set Sunderland up to survive first, attack second. We noticed a compact shape, heavy emphasis on defensive duels, and trust in Robin Roefs behind. His in-game tweaks, like fresh legs in attack, were logical but cautious. There was little risk to chase a winner, even when Villa tired. From our perspective, he deserves credit for the clean sheet but criticism for limited ambition. A pragmatic plan that earned one point yet never really chased three.
Advertisement
Aston Villa Player Ratings vs Sunderland
Here are the Aston Villa Player Ratings from the Aston Villa vs Sunderland Player Ratings.
Goalkeeper
Zion Suzuki - 7: Suzuki had a quieter night than Roefs but still looked very assured. His save from Enzo Le Fée’s late effort was crucial, keeping Villa from a smash-and-grab defeat. On the ball he passed accurately, helping build from the back with confidence. We noticed his positioning on crosses was solid, rarely flapping under pressure. Six ball recoveries showed his alert sweeping behind the high line. Not spectacular, but calm, professional, and deserving of a strong rating.
Defenders
Taylor Harwood-Bellis - 7.5: Harwood-Bellis quietly controlled large portions of the game. Ninety accurate passes from 95 attempted is remarkable, giving Villa structure. He rarely panicked, even when Sunderland pressed sporadically. Defensively, he won all his duels and handled aerial balls confidently. We noticed his calm body language, constantly organizing teammates around him. For us, he was one of Villa’s best performers and a key reason Sunderland rarely threatened.
Pau Torres - 7.5: Pau Torres delivered another cultured display at the back. He touched the ball 100 times and completed 81 passes with high accuracy. Several long balls and 15 passes into the final third helped Villa sustain pressure. Defensively, he made interceptions, a block, and won half his duels. Early in the match he even threatened with a header that drifted wide. From our perspective, his blend of composure and ambition warranted a strong rating.
Ian Maatsen - 6.5: Maatsen’s night was lively but imperfect. He carried real attacking threat, forcing saves from Robin Roefs and taking two shots overall. His passing was clean, and he offered width on the left. However, he lost most of his duels and picked up a yellow card after a rash challenge. We noticed him looking frustrated after several fouls and offside calls. A dangerous presence going forward, but defensive inconsistency keeps his rating moderate.
Aaron Wan-Bissaka - 7.5: Wan-Bissaka was excellent from our perspective. He completed 58 of 62 passes, repeatedly stepping into midfield spaces to progress play. Three successful tackles and two interceptions showed his trademark defensive timing. Offensively, he even contributed a chance created and an assist for a shot. We noticed his confidence growing as the match went on, taking more responsibility on the ball. Despite Sunderland’s counters, he rarely looked truly exposed, fully justifying a high rating.
Advertisement
Midfielders
Boubacar Kamara - 7: Kamara anchored Villa’s midfield with typical authority. He completed 69 of 72 passes, recycling and switching play calmly. His headed assist for Goretzka’s early chance highlighted his set-piece influence. Defensively he battled hard in duels, even if he conceded multiple fouls. From our perspective, he controlled the tempo and gave Villa a secure base. The only downside was a lack of killer vertical passes that might have unlocked Sunderland.
Emiliano Buendía - 7.5: Buendía felt like Villa’s creative heartbeat before his substitution. Four shots, two on target, and three accurate crosses show his intent. He repeatedly tested Roefs from distance and found pockets between Sunderland’s lines. We noticed his body language, demanding the ball and urging teammates forward. Defensively, five recoveries and one tackle underscored his work rate. The missed big chance slightly dents his rating, but overall he was dangerous and lively.
Nicolas Jackson - 6.5: Jackson’s night was more about facilitating than finishing. He only managed one off-target shot, which disappointed us given his talent. Still, three chances created and clever link-up play showed his value between the lines. He combined well with Buendía and Maatsen, dragging defenders out of position. At times his passing accuracy dipped and he drifted out of the box too often. A functional display, but not the ruthless striker Villa needed.
Leon Goretzka - 6.5: Goretzka brought energy but also chaos to midfield. He took two shots, one blocked and one just wide, showing late-box runs. Defensively he competed in many duels and made a few interventions. However, frequent fouls and a yellow card highlighted his reckless side. We noticed moments where he looked frustrated, arguing with the referee and gesturing at teammates. His impact was real but inconsistent, so a mid-range rating feels fair.
Johan Manzambi - 7: Manzambi impressed us before going off. He won six of nine duels, battling hard against Sunderland’s midfield. Two shots, one on target, plus accurate crossing showed his attacking threat. He also worked back diligently, making tackles and a clearance. The early header miss was unfortunate, but his overall contribution was positive. His substitution felt more like rotation than punishment for performance.
Alysson - 6.5: Alysson played a tidy, if unspectacular, role on the right side. He passed reliably with 85% accuracy and helped maintain width. We noticed some heavy touches and four dispossessions, which broke momentum. However, he still created one notable chance and won a few fouls. Defensively he chipped in with an interception and tracked runners decently. A solid cog in the machine, but not a true difference-maker.
Substitutes
Ibrahim Mbaye - 6.5: Mbaye offered fresh legs and aggression after coming on. His long-range shot, tipped over by Roefs, was one of Villa’s better late chances. We noticed him driving forward from midfield, trying to inject urgency. On the ball he was slightly loose but always positive in intent. Defensively he pressed hard, even if it occasionally left space behind. A decent cameo, adding energy but not quite changing the result.
John McGinn - 6.5: McGinn added grit and directness on the left side. He produced a decent shot that flew just wide, showing his trademark late runs. His assist for Mbaye’s effort highlighted his awareness in broken play. We noticed his usual intensity, snapping into duels and shouting instructions. At times he forced passes and shots, reducing composure. A lively substitute appearance, but lacking the final bit of quality.
Ross Barkley - 6: Barkley entered to offer creativity but had limited time to stamp authority. He committed one foul and tried to get on the ball between lines. From our perspective, his movement was good but service into him came late. Sunderland’s compactness restricted his space to turn and drive. No clear chances or decisive passes emerged from his cameo. A low-key contribution in a tight contest.
Brian Madjo - 6: Madjo replaced Jackson and looked eager to run in behind. We noticed his constant movement across the back line, trying to drag defenders. However, the service into him was minimal, with Sunderland sitting deep. He didn’t register meaningful shots or touches in dangerous zones. His impact was therefore mostly tactical rather than statistical. A neutral performance that’s hard to judge harshly or generously.
Manager
U. Emery Etxegoien - 7: Emery’s plan was clear, even if the result frustrated Villa fans. He built play through Harwood-Bellis and Pau Torres, trusting their passing quality. The substitutions of Buendía and Manzambi for fresher legs felt calculated rather than reactive. From our perspective, his side controlled most territory but lacked clinical edge in the box. Sunderland’s resilience and Roefs’ form denied him the win despite a strong structure. Tactically solid, but missing that final attacking spark.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the result of Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
+
What was the result of Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
The Sunderland vs Aston Villa match finished 0-0, a tense Premier League stalemate.
When was Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
+
When was Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
The Sunderland vs Aston Villa match was played during the 2026-27 Premier League season.
Who was the man of the match in Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
+
Who was the man of the match in Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
Robin Roefs was widely considered man of the match in the Sunderland vs Aston Villa clash.
Who was the worst performer in Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
+
Who was the worst performer in Sunderland vs Aston Villa?
Wilson Isidor looked the weakest performer in the Sunderland vs Aston Villa match overall.
Conversation
(0 Comments)
Editor's Pick
Editor's Pick










-1754988285871.webp)
