Crystal Palace 2-1 Newcastle United Player Ratings: Mateta Completes Comeback As The Eagles Bag Late Victory At Selhurst Park

A dramatic conclusion at Selhurst Park as Crystal Palace pulled off a stunning comeback to secure a 2-1 win against Newcastle United in a thrilling Premier League encounter.

The visitors looked comfortable for large spells before a late surge from the Eagles turned everything on its head. Crystal Palace never gave up and fought till the very last minute for the win.

Newcastle United looked to be in control after William Osula poked them ahead just before the break. They managed the game well for the first hour; however, you could feel the momentum shift as Palace started to throw everything forward.

The crowd was getting behind their team, and it genuinely seemed to lift the players on the pitch. The turning point was the introduction of Jean-Philippe Mateta, who headed in an equalizer with ten minutes to go.

The drama peaked in stoppage time when Sven Botman clumsily brought down Jefferson Lerma in the box. Mateta stepped up and coolly dispatched the penalty in the 94th minute, sending the home fans into delirium and snatching all three points.

This match will be remembered for its chaotic and exhilarating finish, which truly lived up to the expectations of a Premier League game.

Here are the Crystal Palace vs Newcastle Player Ratings.

Key Takeaways

• Although Newcastle had more possession, Crystal Palace had a better xG (2.34) and lived up to it.
• Sven Botman won the most aerial duels in this game (8).
• Yeremy Pino and Tyrich Mitchell both had a similar number of key passes in this match (2).

Newcastle United Player Ratings vs Crystal Palace

Have a look at the Newcastle Player Ratings from the Crystal Palace vs Newcastle Player Ratings.

Goalkeeper

Aaron Ramsdale - 6.5: Made a few smart saves in the first half to keep Palace at bay, particularly from Yéremy Pino and Daniel Muñoz. He commanded his area with some confidence, claiming a high ball well. Couldn't do much about either goal. A solid, if unspectacular, outing for the keeper who was let down by his defence in the end.

Defenders

Tino Livramento - 6.0: A mixed bag from Livramento. He showed glimpses of his attacking talent, driving forward and winning a couple of fouls. However, from our perspective, he was too often loose in possession, losing the ball 16 times. Defensively, he was mostly steady but struggled to contain Palace's wide players as the game wore on. An average performance.

Malick Thiaw - 5.5: A difficult evening for the centre-back. While he made five clearances and a few important tackles, he looked nervy throughout. He picked up a yellow card for a clumsy foul and seemed to struggle with the physicality of Palace's forwards in the second half. Not his most composed performance and he was part of a backline that crumbled under pressure.

Sven Botman - 4.0: It was all going reasonably well until it wasn't. Botman was a monster in the air, winning eight aerial duels, and made some key interceptions. But all that is forgotten because of one moment. His clumsy, tired challenge on Lerma to concede the match-losing penalty was inexcusable. A catastrophic error that cost his team the game.

Lewis Hall - 6.5: One of Newcastle's brighter sparks, especially in the first half. He was a willing runner down the left and delivered a great cross for an early Botman chance. Had a decent shot on target himself. He was busy throughout, making five recoveries and two clearances, but faded slightly as Palace took control. A decent showing nonetheless.

Midfielders

Sandro Tonali - 5.5: A very quiet and frustrating game for the Italian. He lost possession an alarming 25 times, which really stalled Newcastle's momentum. While he worked hard and recovered the ball seven times, his passing was uncharacteristically sloppy. He failed to impose himself on the match and his creative spark was completely missing. A disappointing outing.

Lewis Miley - 7.0: The youngster showed maturity beyond his years. He was tidy in possession, rarely giving the ball away and even popped up with an assist for Osula's goal, showing great awareness. He won most of his duels and kept things ticking over in the middle. One of the few Newcastle players who can hold his head high.

Joelinton - 5.0: A really ineffective performance from the Brazilian before being substituted. He struggled to get involved, managing only 36 touches. He lost most of his duels and committed a couple of needless fouls, earning a yellow card. What stood out to us was his inability to provide any defensive cover or forward thrust. Looked off the pace completely.

Anthony Gordon - 6.0: Drew a few fouls and tried to make things happen but it just wasn't his day. He was well-marshalled by the Palace defence and couldn't find the space he thrives in. He had one shot blocked but otherwise offered little threat before being taken off. A hardworking but ultimately fruitless 71 minutes.

Jacob Murphy - 5.0: As captain, you'd expect more. His passing accuracy of 58% was dreadful and he lost possession a staggering 25 times. He offered very little going forward, with his crosses failing to find their mark. While he worked hard defensively, his lack of quality on the ball was a major issue for his team. A poor performance.

Forwards

William Osula - 7.5: Newcastle's best player on the day. He was a constant nuisance for the Palace backline, drawing four fouls and showing good strength. He took his goal well with a sharp poacher's finish from close range. He also had another shot saved. His hold-up play was decent, but he was left isolated as his team retreated in the second half.

Substitutes

Harvey Barnes - 5.5: Came on for Gordon but failed to make any real impact on the game. Seemed to struggle to get up to the speed of the match.

Jacob Ramsey - N/A: Brought on for the final few minutes but had no time to influence the proceedings.

Nick Woltemade - N/A: A late replacement for the goalscorer Osula, barely touched the ball.

Manager

E. Howe - 5.0: His team took the lead and looked set for a professional away win. However, they completely collapsed under second-half pressure. His side looked devoid of ideas once Palace ramped it up, and they failed to manage the final stages of the game. The late capitulation falls on his shoulders as much as the players'.

Crystal Palace Player Ratings vs Newcastle

Check out the Crystal Palace Player Ratings from the Crystal Palace vs Newcastle Player Ratings.

Goalkeeper

Dean Henderson - 6.0: Had very little to do for most of the game. He made two saves, one from a long-range effort from Hall and another to deny Osula. He couldn't be faulted for the goal he conceded. His distribution was a bit shaky, completing only 52% of his passes, but he was secure enough when called upon.

Defenders

Maxence Lacroix - 6.0: A strange performance. He won a remarkable number of aerial duels and made eight clearances, showing his defensive strengths. However, he was also credited with an error leading to a goal, a major black mark against his name. He was physically dominant but that one costly mistake almost proved decisive. A mixed display.

Jaydee Canvot - 7.0: A very solid and composed performance at the back. He was strong in the tackle and read the game well, making six clearances. He was also comfortable on the ball, spraying long passes with an 84% accuracy. Should have scored with a header in the first half but was a reliable presence throughout.

Chris Richards - 6.5: Partnered Canvot well in central defence. Made five clearances and was generally in the right place at the right time. He was a little loose in possession at times, but he grew into the game and helped keep Osula quiet for long periods. A steady and dependable outing.

Midfielders

Daniel Muñoz - 8.0: Our man of the match. An all-action performance from the midfielder who played more like a winger. He was a bundle of energy, making four successful tackles and constantly driving his team forward. He had three shots, two on target, and was a perpetual thorn in Newcastle's side. He committed a few fouls but his aggression was exactly what Palace needed.

Jefferson Lerma - 7.5: The engine in the Palace midfield. He recovered the ball nine times and was everywhere. He was desperately unlucky not to score when his header crashed against the woodwork. Crucially, his smart movement in the box won the game-winning penalty. A tenacious and hugely influential display.

Will Hughes - 6.5: A tidy, if unspectacular, performance before he was subbed. He kept the ball moving and made three interceptions to break up Newcastle's play. He didn't offer a huge amount going forward, but he provided a solid base for others to build from. Did his job effectively.

Tyrick Mitchell - 7.5: Another excellent performance from the full-back. Defensively solid, winning most of his duels and making four tackles. Going forward he was a real threat, and he delivered a perfect cross for Mateta's equalizing goal. A complete performance that showcased both his defensive and offensive qualities.

Forwards

Brennan Johnson - 5.5: A very quiet afternoon for the attacker. He struggled to get into the game and was largely anonymous before his substitution. He lost the ball a few times and couldn't link up with his fellow forwards. It was no surprise to see him taken off after 64 minutes.

Jørgen Strand Larsen - 6.0: Worked hard and put himself about, winning a few aerial battles. However, he offered little in terms of goal threat and was often clumsy in possession, turning the ball over four times. He occupied the defenders but lacked the quality to make a real difference. Replaced by the eventual hero, Mateta.

Yéremy Pino - 7.0: A livewire. He was a constant threat with his movement and creativity. He created two big chances and had a good shot saved in the first half. His final ball was sometimes lacking, but his direct running caused Newcastle problems all game. A very positive and dangerous performance before he was substituted.

Substitutes

Jean-Philippe Mateta - 8.0: The game-changer. Came off the bench and completely turned the match on its head. Scored a brilliant header to equalize and then showed nerves of steel to slot home the winning penalty. A perfect super-sub performance.

Adam Wharton - 6.5: Brought on to add more control in midfield and he did just that. Helped Palace sustain their attacks late on.

Ismaïla Sarr - 6.0: Added some pace and directness in the final stages but didn't have a decisive moment.

Daichi Kamada - 6.0: Looked tidy on the ball after coming on, helping to see out the win.

Manager

O. Glasner - 8.0: His substitutions were absolutely spot on. He recognized his team needed a change, and the introduction of Mateta in particular was a stroke of genius. He deserves huge credit for inspiring the comeback, and his tactical tweaks in the second half were pivotal to the victory. A great day at the office for the manager.

Man of the Match

Jean-Philippe Mateta was adjudged the man of the match in Crystal Palace vs Newcastle.

Worst Performer

Sven Botman was the worst performer from this EPL encounter.