app-icon

SD Live

Fastest Live Scores

Download App
sportsdunia logo
Search Icon

Advertisement

Advertisement

Newcastle United vs Arsenal Player Ratings: Madueke 8.5/10 as Gunners Survives the Magpies In 2-2 Thriller

14 min
Newcastle United vs Arsenal Player Ratings

Arsenal and Newcastle United battled to a breathless 2-2 Premier League draw at St. James' Park on Saturday, as Noni Madueke’s 78th-minute equalizer rescued a point for the league leaders in a thrilling second-half turnaround.

Mikel Arteta’s side initially looked poised to extend their dominant start to the season inside a hostile Tyneside atmosphere, where former Magpies captain Bruno Guimarães was met with loud jeers on every touch. After Madueke struck the post early, Arsenal broke through in the 33rd minute when Eberechi Eze clinically finished a sharp Kai Havertz through ball at the near post for his first league goal of the campaign. Despite controlling the first-half rhythm, the Gunners failed to put the hosts away before the interval.

Newcastle manager Matthias Jaissle sparked an immediate transformation with a bold triple substitution at halftime, introducing Valentino Livramento, Anthony Elanga, and Matias Fernandez-Pardo. The hosts seized total control after the restart, leveling in the 52nd minute when William Osula robbed Martin Odegaard and teed up Harvey Barnes to slot past David Raya. Ten minutes later, Malick Thiaw stabbed home from a chaotic Lewis Hall corner, surviving a tense VAR offside check, to complete Newcastle's comeback before Raya was forced off with an arm injury. Just as the Magpies looked set to hand Arsenal only their second defeat of the season, Odegaard slipped Madueke through on a swift counterattack to fire home the 78th-minute leveler. Here are the full Newcastle United vs Arsenal player ratings from St. James' Park.

Advertisement

Xellion Banner

Arsenal Player Ratings vs Newcastle United

Have a look at the Arsenal player ratings from the Newcastle United vs Arsenal player ratings.

Goalkeeper

David Raya - 6: Raya’s evening felt strangely disrupted, and we noticed his rhythm never settled. He made a solid save from Lewis Miley, parrying well under pressure. However, his long distribution often surrendered possession too cheaply and invited pressure back. Conceding two goals, he was hardly catastrophic, but he did not command his box enough. The repeated injury delays clearly knocked his confidence and timing. Overall, a middling display before injury forced him off.

Kepa Arrizabalaga - 6.5: Coming in cold on 70 minutes at St. James' is no easy task. He looked calm, even slightly detached, which actually helped under the late aerial bombardment. Newcastle’s continuous corners tested his positioning, yet he maintained decent starting positions. He did not have a major save to make but dealt cleanly with crosses. We felt his composure steadied Arsenal’s back line in a frantic finale.

Defenders

Gabriel - 6.5: Gabriel had one of those rugged nights where he fought constantly but not always cleanly. His passing was very reliable, with 96% accuracy, helping Arsenal build from deep. Yet he conceded dangerous corners and a few needless fouls around the box. We saw frustration in his gestures after Thiaw’s set-piece goal. In the duels, he was competitive but sometimes late against Osula’s physicality. A committed showing, just lacking true dominance.

Jurriën Timber - 6.5: Timber gave Arsenal width and energy on the right, frequently pushing high to support attacks. One clever overlapping run produced Havertz’s early chance, showing his offensive instincts. Defensively, he handled most one‑v‑one situations, winning a majority of his duels. But we felt he was occasionally caught high when Newcastle broke quickly. His passing was solid, if not spectacular, and he kept recycling possession intelligently. Overall, a decent but not standout full‑back performance.

Ezri Konsa - 7: Konsa quietly stitched together a strong outing at center-back from our perspective. He read danger nicely and produced several key clearances under pressure. A high pass accuracy and one clever key pass hinted at his composure on the ball. He consistently won fouls to relieve pressure and stepped in aggressively when needed. At times Newcastle’s movement did drag him wide, but he remained fairly composed. One of Arsenal’s more reliable defenders on the night.

Riccardo Calafiori - 6.5: Calafiori contributed well in possession, linking neatly with midfield on the left. We noticed his confidence when stepping into space to carry the ball forward. Defensively, he cleared danger a couple of times and read passing lanes well. However, he wasted a promising attacking shot, slicing wide from the box. His aerial dominance was impressive with perfect win percentage. Overall, a competent performance, just lacking a defining moment.

Advertisement

Midfielders

Declan Rice - 6.5: Rice worked tirelessly, and his ten ball recoveries show that typical defensive grind. We saw him repeatedly slide across to cover transitions, often bailing out advanced full‑backs. On the ball, he was neat, spreading play and hitting a few penetrating passes. Yet his big missed chance from outside the box felt costly in hindsight. The yellow card and late fouls suggested rising frustration. Solid, but not the commanding performance we expected from him.

Bruno Guimarães - 6: It was strange seeing Bruno in an Arsenal shirt, and he never fully convinced. He missed a huge close‑range chance that could have buried the game early. We noticed his passing tempo was fine but not truly incisive, often safe. Defensively, he committed fouls and conceded corners, dragging his rating down. His body language looked slightly irritated after losing several duels in midfield. Subbed on at 70 minutes, his influence ended up limited.

Martin Ødegaard - 7: Ødegaard’s performance was mixed but ultimately decisive. He orchestrated play with sharp passing and two key passes into dangerous zones. His assist for Madueke’s 2-2 equalizer was perfectly weighted and calmly executed. However, an error leading to goal from a set‑piece situation really hurt Arsenal. We saw him gesturing furiously, trying to reorganize the pressing after Newcastle’s comeback. Overall, his creativity and leadership still justified a positive rating.

Eberechi Eze - 8: For us, Eze was arguably Arsenal’s brightest spark and close to man of the match. His opening goal, a top‑corner finish from Havertz’s through ball, oozed confidence and class. Beyond the goal, he constantly demanded the ball, drifting between lines and causing panic. He created chances with clever passes, and his chemistry with Madueke looked natural. Even his long‑range effort before half‑time forced Hornicek into a strong save. Taken off on 70 minutes, his absence coincided with Arsenal’s slight loss of control.

Noni Madueke - 8.5: Madueke was, from our perspective, the highest‑rated performer on the pitch. He was electric from the first whistle, smashing the post after six minutes. Despite missing several chances and even hitting the woodwork, he kept demanding the ball. His eventual equalizer for 2-2 showed real composure, slamming low into the corner. Six shots, multiple dribbles, and persistent movement terrified Newcastle’s left side all night. The yellow card and a couple of big chances missed stop a perfect rating, but he still stood out massively.

Forwards

Kai Havertz - 7: Havertz quietly knitted Arsenal’s attack together with clever movement and subtle link‑up play. His through ball for Eze’s opener was inch‑perfect and timed brilliantly. We noticed him dropping off the line to create space for Madueke’s runs. He only had one shot, missing narrowly, which felt slightly underwhelming for a striker. Defensively he contributed with clearances and one strong tackle, helping on set pieces. Overall, a good, intelligent performance, just lacking a goal.

Advertisement

Substitutes

Myles Lewis-Skelly - 6.5: Coming on at 70 minutes, Lewis‑Skelly showed mature composure for his age. He won multiple free kicks late, easing pressure during Newcastle’s final push. His positioning in the defensive half impressed us, rarely vacating his zone recklessly. On the ball, he kept it simple, recycling possession instead of forcing risky passes. We sensed he grew in confidence with each successful intervention. A promising cameo that hinted at future responsibility.

Christos Tzolis - 6: Tzolis entered with attacking intent but found space hard to come by. He was flagged offside once, which highlighted slightly over‑eager runs behind. In possession, he kept things neat without truly piercing Newcastle’s deep line. We wanted more direct dribbling or shots from him in that period. Still, his presence stretched the hosts a little and created half‑gaps for others. A modest impact overall.

Manager

Mikel Arteta - 7: Arteta’s plan worked brilliantly in the first half, exploiting Newcastle’s left side. His use of Madueke and Eze between the lines repeatedly unbalanced Jaissle’s structure. However, set‑piece frailty and momentum loss after half‑time undermined that control. We felt his triple substitution on 70 minutes was bold, especially withdrawing Eze. Yet the side still found a way back, reflecting his attacking mentality. Overall, a sensible strategy with some risky changes that nearly backfired.

Advertisement

Newcastle United Player Ratings vs Arsenal

Here are the Newcastle United player ratings from the Newcastle United vs Arsenal player ratings.

Goalkeeper

Lukas Hornicek - 7: Hornicek faced waves of Arsenal attacks, especially in that frantic first half. He produced important saves from Madueke and Eze, keeping Newcastle in the game. His long distribution was very aggressive, launching 27 long balls to escape pressure. We noticed occasional inaccuracy, but it did stretch Arsenal’s defensive line. Commanding his box, he punched and claimed high balls with confidence. Conceding two well‑taken goals, he still walked away with credit.

Defenders

Lewis Hall - 5.5: Hall had a really up‑and‑down evening, and we found him frustrating to watch. He conceded multiple fouls and even a corner that led to sustained pressure. His crossing was inconsistent, with only one accurate ball from five attempts. The error leading to Arsenal’s goal summed up his shaky defending. At times his body language looked anxious, glancing at teammates after mistakes. Some decent recoveries, but overall one of Newcastle’s weaker performers.

Dan Burn - 7: Burn battled relentlessly, especially aerially, against Arsenal’s varied attacking shape. His clearances and blocks under pressure were vital as the game became stretched. We saw him win most of his duels, using his frame to dominate physically. He also created a chance from a header after a corner, showing attacking threat. The yellow card came from a late, heavy challenge as frustration boiled over. Despite that, he was a key defensive leader on the night.

Malick Thiaw - 8: Thiaw’s display really caught our eye, particularly in the second half. Defensively, he was solid, winning every duel and every aerial he contested. He read counters well, making six ball recoveries and stepping into passing lanes. Most importantly, he scored Newcastle’s second goal, reacting sharply from a corner. That close‑range finish after VAR confirmation completely flipped the momentum inside the stadium. His mixture of composure and aggression makes this an excellent, high‑impact performance.

Amar Dedic - 6: Dedic’s first‑half shift was combative but a little reckless. He picked up a yellow for a bad foul, which changed his tackling approach. We noticed him trying to calm himself afterwards, playing safer passes and positions. Defensively, he won some duels and put in a few solid tackles. However, Arsenal exploited his side with Madueke’s direct running. Subbed at half‑time, his impact was limited and slightly negative overall.

Advertisement

Midfielders

Joe Willock - 7.5: Willock played like a chaos agent, constantly involved in the game’s wildest moments. He created chances, registered an assist for Thiaw’s goal, and drove forward relentlessly. At the same time, he missed several shots, some wildly off target from good positions. We saw his work rate and pressing really unsettle Arsenal’s midfield. Defensively, he made tackles and recovered the ball eight times, covering huge ground. Despite wastefulness, his overall influence was very strong.

Lewis Miley - 7: Miley impressed us with his maturity and calm decisions under intense pressure. His passing accuracy was excellent, rarely wasting the ball in tight spaces. He produced one dangerous shot from distance, forcing Raya into a fine save. Defensively, he recovered possession and intercepted passes smartly, reading Arsenal’s patterns. His cross and forward deliveries helped Newcastle maintain pressure late on. For such a young midfielder, this was a quietly assured performance.

Harvey Barnes - 7.5: Barnes’ equalizer at 1-1 shifted the entire energy of the match. He finished calmly from the center of the box after Osula’s smart assist. Beyond the goal, his pace on the break caused Arsenal real problems. We saw him win fouls, drive at defenders, and link effectively with Willock. The yellow card and some lost duels show he lived on the edge. Overall, though, his impact on the scoreline was significant.

Sean Steur - 6: Steur’s first‑half contribution was tidy but unspectacular. He kept the ball moving with high pass accuracy and simple distribution. Defensively, he chipped in with one tackle and a few positional recoveries. Subbed at half‑time, likely for tactical reasons rather than poor form. A functional, low‑profile performance.

Jacob Murphy - 6.5: Murphy’s 45 minutes were a mix of ambition and wastefulness. He attempted long‑range efforts, one from over 35 yards that drifted wide. Another shot from outside the box was blocked after good buildup. He maintained perfect pass accuracy, though the volume was very low. We liked his willingness to shoot, even if the execution lacked precision. Replaced at the break as Jaissle sought fresh energy on the flanks.

Lewis Hall - 5.5: Already rated above, Hall’s role in midfield phases deserves another brief mention. He drifted between full‑back and wide midfield, sometimes confusing defensive coverage. That hybrid positioning created passing options but also left space for Arsenal’s wide overloads. We noticed teammates signaling to him to tuck in more often. He will likely learn from this chaotic, difficult outing.

Forwards

William Osula - 7: Osula offered non‑stop running and physical presence up front. His assist for Barnes’ equalizer showcased clever movement and awareness in the box. He also laid off passes to create chances for Willock and others. However, he lost many duels and spent time arguing with the referee after fouls. We felt his pressing was valuable but occasionally too aggressive, causing cheap free kicks. Overall, he contributed well to Newcastle’s comeback despite some rough edges.

Advertisement

Fanatics Banner

Substitutes

Jacob Ramsey - 6.5: Ramsey’s introduction added energy and more vertical runs from midfield. He assisted Lewis Miley’s shot with a neat layoff around the box. In possession, he tried to carry the ball forward, sometimes overdoing touches slightly. Defensively, he conceded a foul but worked hard to track back. We sensed he wanted to make a statement but lacked the final killer action. Still, a positive, lively cameo.

Tino Livramento - 6.5: Livramento came on and instantly gave Newcastle more drive down the flank. He won a free kick on the left wing, pushing Arsenal backwards late on. His defensive positioning looked disciplined, rarely diving in recklessly. With the ball, he offered overlaps, though end product remained limited. A decent impact substitute performance.

Anthony Elanga - 6.5: Elanga brought pace and direct runs into channels after half‑time. His presence stretched Arsenal’s back line, even without clear shots on goal. We saw him time runs better than Murphy, especially in transition moments. Still, he lacked a defining final ball or chance to really shine. He helped maintain Newcastle’s territorial pressure in the second half. A solid, hard‑working cameo.

Yoane Wissa - 6: Wissa arrived late and had limited time to affect proceedings. He pressed Arsenal’s defenders and tried to occupy central spaces. On the ball, he received few touches, as Newcastle mostly attacked via wide areas. We were hoping for one big chance that never quite materialized. Defensively, he helped on set pieces with his positioning. Hard to judge him too harshly given the short minutes.

Manager

Marco Jaissle - 7.5: Jaissle’s halftime adjustments changed the entire feel of this Newcastle United performance. Bringing on Ramsey, Elanga, and Livramento injected energy and aggression into wide areas. His insistence on exploiting set pieces paid off with Thiaw’s goal. We noticed him constantly urging his players forward even after taking the lead. The only slight criticism is letting the game become too open at 2-1. Still, drawing 2-2 against Arsenal after trailing shows a strong tactical response.

Advertisement

Remitly

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the result of Newcastle United vs Arsenal?

+

The Newcastle United vs Arsenal match finished in a 2-2 draw, with momentum swings.

When was Newcastle United vs Arsenal?

+

The Newcastle United vs Arsenal match took place on 21 November 2026 in Premier League.

Who was the man of the match in Newcastle United vs Arsenal?

+

From our perspective, Noni Madueke was man of the match in Newcastle United vs Arsenal.

Who was the worst performer in Newcastle United vs Arsenal?

+

Lewis Hall looked the worst performer in the Newcastle United vs Arsenal match overall.

Conversation

(0 Comments)

Loading comments...
Follow Us:
sportsdunia google newssportsdunia google news

Editor's Pick