Top 10 Games Like Until Dawn: Horror and Interactive Story Experiences

If you have had the opportunity to play Until Dawn, you already know just how powerful a story-driven horror game can be. It features tense decisions, fleshed-out characters, and scenarios that might even thrill you to the point of your heart racing.

What makes horror video games so unique is that your choices will matter, impacting who lives or dies and what unfolds over the night. If you enjoy cinematic horror, there is plenty of additional gaming to be had beyond that one experience. Psychological thrillers, multiplayer survival experiences, and more all provide just a sample of what Until Dawn brings to the table. Here is a full list of games like Until Dawn you can try out today.

Top 10 Best Games Like Until Dawn

These games were selected for their compelling narratives, spooky horror, and player choices. Some prioritise psychological horror while others feature survival horror or thrilling narratives. If you're someone who prefers puzzle-like titles, then check out our recent coverage on NYT Worldle-like games. As for this article, however, we have provided a glimpse of the top 10 games that are like Until Dawn below​:

Each game has a unique characteristic, whether it is survival, heavy emotional choice consequences, or world immersion. Let’s dive into each game like Until Dawn, in detail.

10. Erica

Erica is a live-action interactive thriller in which each choice you make affects the overall story. You take control of Erica, a young woman who is investigating the dark past of her family.

The game combines cinematic storytelling with interactive moments to create an intimate experience that feels very much like you are involved in a mystery movie. It is a relatively short game but heavy on suspense and intrigue. However, depending on the decisions you make, Erica has replay appeal since it offers different decision paths and alternate endings. It is one of the more popular games like Until Dawn.

9. Layers of Fear

Layers of Fear provides a mashed-up experience that ties many elements from previous entries, now refined into a psychological horror experience. The player walks through the world that includes a haunted lighthouse, examining disturbing imagery and unravelling bizarre narratives.

Each decision shapes how the narrative later unfolds, constructing surreal imagery and blended sound that keeps you immersed in the moment. The experience of this game can lead to questioning what is real. It easily ranks among the top games like Until Dawn​.

8. Beyond: Two Souls

Beyond: Two Souls follows Jodie Holmes, a young woman who is linked to a supernatural entity. The game spans a wider range of time, visually moving through the course of her life. The game blends cinematic scenes and interactive decision-making moments.

Every decision you make in the game has consequences on the course of Jodie’s relationships and the eventual outcome of her future. While the game leans into drama rather than horror, the suspense and emotional element of Jodie’s arc are more than enough to entertain the fans of games like Until Dawn.

7. Dead by Daylight

Dead by Daylight is an asymmetric multiplayer horror game where one player is the killer, and four players are survivors. The excitement of Dead by Daylight comes from the unpredictability of each match. The survivors must outsmart the killer while repairing generators and hiding in a range of environments.

The tension is solid, but it comes from the variety of killers to choose from, each offers different ways to attack the survivors. Dead by Daylight is not scripted horror: every round feels different, making gameplay endless fun for horror fans.

6. Silent Hill 2 Remake

The Silent Hill 2 Remake is a revisit of the classic psychological horror title for a new generation. You assume the role of James Sunderland, who is travelling to a fog-covered town to find his missing wife.

The remake instils fear with its advanced visual and audio design. The choices you make in the remake affect character interactions. It also slightly adjusts outcomes, providing multiple layers of tension in the story.

5. House of Ashes

Part of the Dark Pictures Anthology, House of Ashes puts you inside a Sumerian temple. You are part of a group stuck underground, being hunted by creatures from the past. The gameplay is a film viewed through the lens of gameplay, creating a cinematic experience with tense moments and combat, accompanied by selection paths.

As the player, you get to make decisions on which characters live or die. The blend of group and horror with some quick-paced scares makes this game a thrilling experience.

4. Little Nightmares III

Little Nightmares III keeps true to the series tradition. Players find themselves in The Nowhere, a realm filled with grotesque monsters and surreal environments.

The game introduces online co-op gameplay where players must work together to solve puzzles to survive. Little Nightmares III is less choice-based than previous games in the series, but the atmosphere and unsettling visuals are no less solid than horror games like Until Dawn.

3. Detroit: Become Human

Detroit: Become Human also ranks among the games that are like Until Dawn. It is a narrative-driven sci-fi thriller, where players control a group of androids forced to question their morals. Every action has consequences, often affecting characters and story arcs.

Overall, this game excels at storytelling with strong emotional elements and offers audiences dozens of possible endings. Although it is listed as a sci-fi adventure, if you are an Until Dawn fan who enjoys branching narratives, Detroit: Become Human is a superb choice as well.

2. Oxenfree

In Oxenfree, a group of friends accidentally open a ghostly rift on an abandoned island, and this is where this supernatural thriller begins. This game has varied outcomes depending on player decisions. Unlike conventional horror experiences, this game emphasises exploration.

Although the game features moments of subtle jump scares and atmosphere, it is entirely dependent on specific moods, suspense, and player choices. That is why it is going to be an unreal experience for the fans of Until Dawn like games

1. The Quarry

No. 1 on the list, without a hint of doubt, is The Quarry. This horror title is considered to be a spiritual successor to Until Dawn. In this game, players fill the shoes of a group of camp counsellors who will come across dreadful events at a remote summer camp.

The most exciting thing about this game is that it features more than 180 possible outcomes depending on player choices, which is a dream come true for Until Dawn fans. Also, it features superb graphics and lifelike character animations. It is also a popular game like Until Dawn.

Similar to this piece, we also recently covered a full list of games like Stardew Valley. You can check that out on our official website.