Alexander Isak vs Gyokeres: Whom to pick in Your FPL Team?

When it comes to creating the best Fantasy Premier League (FPL) team for the 2025/26 season, the striking choices are aplenty, but two names catching serious attention are Alexander Isak and Viktor Gyokeres. Both forwards have shone in recent seasons and come with distinct strengths, prices, and potential point returns, making their comparison an intriguing challenge. This breakdown aims to help FPL managers decide who deserves a spot up front by exploring their attributes, recent performances, pricing, and fixtures.

Alexander Isak – The Proven Premier League Elite

Alexander Isak, now a Liverpool player, has cemented his reputation as one of the Premier League’s most lethal forwards. In the 2024/25 season, Isak scored 23 goals and provided six assists in 34 appearances, finishing as the top-scoring FPL forward with 211 points, and he is predicted to score even more points this season. His output reflects not just goal-scoring but also his involvement in play, with Opta analyst David Segar highlighting Isak’s average 36.8 touches per 90 minutes, showcasing his role beyond just finishing. With a price tag of £10.5m, he offers great value compared to the priciest forwards without compromising on big-point potential.
Key strengths include a superb non-penalty shot conversion rate of 26.4%, ranked higher than even Erling Haaland and Mohamed Salah last season. Isak’s consistency extends to scoring in big games against traditional top-six clubs and his ability to find chances inside the box, evidenced by 46 shots on target and 36 big chances last season. The 2025/26 season sees Liverpool, a team thriving on creative attacking play, as his platform, promising plenty of service and opportunities to maintain or surpass last year’s scoring levels.
One consideration for managers is the current uncertainty around Isak’s full integration into the Liverpool squad, given recent transfer and injury news, which may affect his availability early in the season. But once settled, Isak remains a top-tier forward with more than enough ability to justify a premium FPL forward slot.

Viktor Gyokeres – The Emerging Arsenal Threat

Viktor Gyokeres is Arsenal’s marquee striker signing with expectations high after his sensational goal-scoring record at Sporting CP, where he notched 54 goals and 13 assists in the 2024/25 season alone. Priced at a much more budget-friendly £9.0m, Gyokeres presents a compelling differential for managers looking to save funds without sacrificing points potential.
Arsenal’s fluid attacking style under Mikel Arteta is built to maximize a striker’s impact, combining high pressing, positional dominance, and creative outlets from players like Ødegaard and Saka. Gyokeres benefits from this system as the focal point of Arsenal’s attack and assumes penalty duties, a big plus in FPL scoring. His penalty conversion record is outstanding, scoring 34 of 38 spot-kicks in his career, with 19 penalties alone last season.
Despite these promising attributes, Gyokeres’ integration into Arsenal’s attacking system is a work in progress. The Swiss forward might not hit the ground running, and Arsenal’s tough early fixtures against clubs like Manchester City and Liverpool could delay his FPL rise. That said, FPL forecasts indicate Gyokeres is predicted to score between 205-235 points over the season if he adapts well, making him a potentially explosive budget option.

Comparing Isak and Gyokeres in FPL Context

*Note: Gyokeres’ goal and assist stats come from the Portuguese league and all competitions, which are highly impressive but from a different league standard.
The fundamental difference between Isak vs Gyokeres boils down to reliability versus potential differential. Isak is a proven force in the Premier League with a high volume of points and fewer concerns about rotation or adaptation. His somewhat higher price reflects that security, but it may limit funds for other areas of your squad.
Gyokeres, on the other hand, offers tantalizing upside at a lower price, freeing up budget elsewhere and providing an opportunity to stand out with a differential pick. If he blossoms in Arsenal’s system and captures penalty spot duties consistently, he could challenge the best forwards for FPL points, especially once Arsenal’s fixture list eases.

Strategic Takeaway for FPL Managers

For those building a best-in-class FPL team, the choice between Isak vs Gyokeres depends on budget flexibility and risk appetite. If budget is no object and a consistent, near-certain source of goals is crucial, Isak is the safer pick. Liverpool’s attacking philosophy and his proven record make him a powerhouse pick for captaincy or steady returns.
Conversely, for managers seeking value and a differential edge, Gyokeres represents a savvy gamble. At £9.0m, he provides the space to invest in premium midfielders or defenders while possessing significant upside thanks to his goal-scoring pedigree and likely penalty duties. Keeping an eye on his role solidifying through early gameweeks will be key before making a full commitment.
In essence, Isak versus Gyokeres is a classic stable stalwart versus high-ceiling dynamo debate that will excite both seasoned FPL strategists and casual managers alike.

Conclusion

Choosing between Alexander Isak and Viktor Gyokeres for your FPL team in the 2025/26 season mirrors a battle of different but equally appealing styles of investment. Isak offers a proven Premier League pedigree, consistent FPL output, and the club environment of Liverpool to support him, while Gyokeres is an emerging force with a lower price and high goal-scoring potential linked to Arsenal’s attack and penalty prospects.
For managers with the budget and desire for stability, Isak remains a must-have premium forward. However, Gyokeres is rapidly becoming the best budget challenger and a smart differential pick for those willing to back Arsenal’s style and his adaptation curve. Whichever way managers lean, both are exciting picks promising thrilling FPL seasons ahead.
This exciting duel continues the tradition of fantasy striker battles that captivate managers every season and will be one to watch closely in the opening weeks.