VAR Inconsistency Sparks Fury: Why Calvert-Lewin Escaped Red for Hair Pull While Martinez Was Banned

A brand-new VAR controversy has taken centre stage following the conclusion of the FA Cup semifinal clash between English giants Chelsea and Leeds United on Sunday, 26th April 2026. Chelsea book FA Cup final berth thanks to Enzo Fernández's header in a 1-0 win. The incident in question happened between the Whites striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Blues defender Marc Cucurella in the 30th minute of the must-win clash. The Englishman reportedly was spotted pulling the hair and yanking the head of the Spaniard back near the byline.

The moment was replayed by broadcasters multiple times on the screen, and fans can clearly see Calvert-Lewin hair pull on Cucurella. On-field VAR review by referee Jarred Gillett cleared the incident to be 'non-violent,' and no card was shown to the Leeds United striker. Fans were seen raising major questions about the infringement made by Calvert-Lewin on Sunday, and asking the question: “Why no red card Calvert-Lewin?”

Chelsea VAR Controversy: Are Inconsistent Decisions Hurting The Game?

The recent incident involving Cucurella and Calvert-Lewin has shed new light on the inconsistency in refereeing decisions despite the presence of the VAR system in major tournaments. The Chelsea VAR controversy has raised fresh questions about how the match officials have determined an incident to be ‘violent’ or ‘non-violent’.

One of the biggest questions emerging due to the incident is the suspension that was handed to Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez following their clash against Leeds United in matchweek 32. The Lisandro Martinez red card hair pull was a similar offence that Calvert-Lewin committed on Cucurella on Sunday, but the Argentine's action was deemed to be violent conduct and resulted in a three-game suspension.

What Happens Next After The VAR Controversy?

The two incidents, while similar in nature, seem to differ only in the interpretation made by the match officials during the two games in question. While talking about the controversial nature of the decision and inconsistency in VAR decisions, former Premier League referee Graham Scott stated:

It will be interesting to see how the FA responds to this recent controversy, which seems to involve VAR and a lack of consistency in decision-making.