Como 0-0 Atalanta Player Ratings: Marco Carnesecchi's Penalty Save Secures A 0-0 Draw

Como 1907 did almost everything right in this Serie A encounter, yet the scoreboard remained frozen at 0-0, delivering one of the most frustrating results of their season. From the opening whistle, the hosts dictated the tempo, boxed Atalanta BC deep inside their own half, and created a relentless stream of clear-cut chances.

The visitors survived not through control or an attacking threat, but through resistance. Time and again, Atalanta were forced to rely on last-ditch defending and the brilliance of their goalkeeper. Marco Carnesecchi produced a performance that bordered on unreal, turning away effort after effort as Como 1907 laid siege to his goal.

The night’s defining moment came in stoppage time when Como were handed a penalty; a final chance to turn dominance into victory. Once again, Carnesecchi stood firm, denying Nico Paz from the spot and sealing a result that felt like a win for Atalanta and a crushing disappointment for the home side. Sportsdunia brings you the Como vs Atalanta player ratings from a Serie A contest that will be remembered more for the impact than the scoreline.

Key Takeaways

• The home side completely controlled the match, creating a flood of chances but failing to convert any of them.
• Atalanta’s goalkeeper produced one of the finest goalkeeping displays of the Serie A season to keep his side alive.
• Nico Paz’s stoppage-time penalty miss summed up Como’s night of frustration in front of goal.

Como Player Ratings vs Atalanta

Check out Como player ratings from the game:

Goalkeeper

Jean Butez - 6.5: Honestly, he could have brought a book to read for most of the game. He had almost nothing to do as his team laid siege to the other end. Made a couple of comfortable saves when called upon. The yellow card seemed a bit unnecessary. A very quiet day at the office for the Como keeper.

Defenders

Marc Oliver Kempf - 7.5: An absolute beast in the air, winning a staggering 11 aerial duels. He was a pillar of strength at the back, repelling what little Atalanta threw forward. His passing was crisp, initiating attacks from deep. He even got forward for a chance of his own. A very commanding performance.

Álex Valle - 7.0: A bundle of energy down the left flank. He was constantly looking to get forward and support the attack, even creating a big chance. Defensively, he was caught out a couple of times but his recovery pace often helped. A solid, all-action display from the fullback.

Jacobo Ramón - 8.0: We are still trying to figure out how he didn't score. He had six shots and missed four big chances. It's a testament to his all-around game that he still gets a high rating. He was everywhere, making tackles, driving forward, and constantly arriving in dangerous positions. If he had his shooting boots on, he'd be getting a 10.

Ivan Smolcic - 7.0: The quiet achiever in the backline. He was positionally sound, made his tackles cleanly, and was reliable in possession. He didn't produce any highlight-reel moments, but he didn't need to. A thoroughly professional and effective performance.

Midfielders

Nico Paz - 5.5: A truly gut-wrenching day for the midfielder. He was involved, he had his shots, but this game will only be remembered for one thing. The missed penalty. To have the game at your feet in stoppage time and fail to convert is a heavy burden. It completely overshadows the rest of his performance.

Martin Baturina - 8.5: What a majestic performance. He was the conductor of the orchestra, creating an incredible seven key passes. He threaded balls through the eye of a needle and was the creative heart of everything good Como did. It's a footballing crime that none of his sublime passes resulted in an assist. He deserved so much more.

Máximo Perrone - 6.0: A neat and tidy performance before his substitution. He kept the ball moving but struggled to make a telling impact in the final third. Picked up an early yellow card and was largely on the periphery of the main action. Did his job without standing out.

Lucas Da Cunha - 8.0: The captain led from the front with a display full of guile and creativity. Four key passes and a big chance created tells its own story. He was a constant threat with his delivery and movement. You could see his frustration grow as his teammates spurned the chances he created. A brilliant individual effort.

Forwards

Anastasios Douvikas - 4.5: A complete shocker. This was one of the worst striking displays of the season. To miss four big chances in under an hour is unforgivable at this level. His finishing was abysmal and he single-handedly let Atalanta off the hook. Hooked before the hour mark, and it wasn't a surprise.

Mërgim Vojvoda - 6.0: Played the first half and was a willing runner. He got into some good positions and had a couple of efforts on goal. However, he lacked the quality to make the decisive breakthrough. An energetic but ultimately fruitless 45 minutes.

Manager

F. Fàbregas i Soler - 6.5: He must be absolutely bewildered. His tactical plan worked to perfection; his team dominated possession, territory, and chances created. They were camped in Atalanta's half. But you can't go on the pitch and score the goals for your players. His system created a conveyor belt of opportunities that were inexplicably wasted.

Atalanta Player Ratings vs Como

Here are the Atalanta Player Ratings from the match against Como:

Goalkeeper

Marco Carnesecchi - 9.5: The Man of the Match. The hero. The savior. Call him what you want. This was a legendary goalkeeping performance. Nine saves, with eight coming from inside the box, is a phenomenal statistic. The dramatic penalty save in stoppage time was the defining moment of a flawless display. He earned Atalanta this point all by himself and was the highest-rated player on the pitch.

Defenders

Berat Djimsiti - 7.5: A warrior's performance. He threw his body on the line time and time again, racking up nine clearances. With his team under constant pressure, he stood tall and battled for every ball. A gutsy, old-school defensive display that was crucial to securing the clean sheet.

Giorgio Scalvini - 6.0: For 90 minutes, he was immense, making 10 clearances and several key blocks. He was a rock. But football can be cruel. His one mistake was conceding the late penalty, a rash challenge that nearly undid all his hard work. His rating suffers massively for that single moment of madness.

Honest Ahanor - 3.0: What was he thinking? To come on as a substitute and get a straight red card after just eight minutes is inexcusable. He left his team in the lurch at a critical moment. A truly disastrous and brainless cameo appearance.

Midfielders

Éderson - 7.5: A one-man wrecking crew in midfield. He made six tackles and three interceptions, constantly breaking up Como's rhythm. While his team was on the back foot, he was one of the few who took the fight to the opposition. A tireless and combative performance.

Marten de Roon - 6.5: The captain fought hard but it was a struggle. He was often bypassed by Como's slick midfield passing. He put in the work, winning all his tackles, but he struggled to get a foothold in the game and his yellow card was a result of his frustration.

Lorenzo Bernasconi - 6.5: A disciplined performance on the wing. He spent most of the match tracking back and defending, contributing with important tackles and clearances. He offered little going forward, but that wasn't really his job today. He stuck to his task diligently.

Davide Zappacosta - 6.0: He worked tirelessly but his quality on the ball let him down. He lost possession 16 times, which is far too high. While his effort couldn't be faulted, he was a source of turnovers that invited more pressure onto his team.

Forwards

Gianluca Scamacca - 5.0: A ghost. He was on the pitch for 18 minutes, had one touch, and was then substituted. We can only assume it was due to an injury because he was completely anonymous. A non-factor in the game.

Charles De Ketelaere - 5.5: It was a tough day for the forward. He lost 11 of his 13 duels, constantly being outmuscled by the Como defence. He did manage to create one big chance, a brief flash of quality in an otherwise difficult outing where he failed to make any real impression.

Nicola Zalewski - 5.5: Another attacker who offered very little. He was hooked at half-time after a first half where he was completely shut down. He couldn't get into the game at all and the substitution was entirely justified.

Manager

R. Palladino - 7.0: His team got battered from start to finish. They were outplayed, out-thought, and out-shot. And yet, they leave with a point. He has his goalkeeper to thank, but the defensive resilience and refusal to break under immense pressure is also a credit to his organization. He'll take this result and run.

Man of the Match

Sportsdunia's player of the match was Marco Carnesecchi.

Worst Performer

Anastasios Douvikas was the worst performer in the Como vs Atalanta.