Fiorentina vs Juventus Player Ratings: Woltemade 8.5/10 as Pellegrino shines but Bremer rescues a 2-2 draw

What we watched at Serie A's classic between Fiorentina and Juventus felt like two different games stitched together. Fiorentina flew out, rode the early wave, and punched hard through their young core, yet somehow Juventus kept hanging around and then clawed back. From our perspective the 2-2 draw at Stadio Artemio Franchi felt fair on the balance, but neither side looked fully satisfied walking off.

We noticed how quickly Fiorentina targeted Juventus on set pieces, with Mateo Pellegrino and Alieu Njie both striking from close range. The visitors though, leaned on quality in transition and relentless crossing, highlighted by Nick Woltemade’s composed finish and Bremer’s scrappy equaliser after a corner. Watching it live, our sense was that this Fiorentina vs Juventus clash will go down as one of those matches both coaches replay in their heads for days.

What stood out to us was the contrast in structure and spontaneity. Fiorentina’s attacks felt rehearsed, layered, everything driven by their midfield trio plus Pote’s class in wide zones. Juventus instead rode individual brilliance; Randal Kolo Muani in particular kept dragging them up the pitch almost by force. In the end, the shared spoils keep both clubs hovering in their respective positions, but individually there were some very big winners, and a couple of worrying dips. Check out the Fiorentina vs Juventus player ratings.

Fiorentina Player Ratings vs Juventus

Here are the Fiorentina player ratings from the Fiorentina vs Juventus player ratings.

Goalkeeper

David de Gea - 5.5: From our perspective this was a strangely jittery display. He produced four saves, including two strong stops from Juan Cabal that kept Fiorentina ahead early on. However, that error leading to a goal hangs over his performance like a cloud. His handling on corners never fully convinced, and Juventus clearly sensed vulnerability under the high ball. We noticed him shouting at his defenders a lot, maybe trying to mask his own unease. With two goals conceded and one clear mistake, a below-average rating feels unavoidable.

Defenders

Radu Drăgușin - 6: Drăgușin’s night felt like a tug-of-war between bravery and rashness. He finished with five clearances and even stepped up with a blocked shot, showing his usual willingness to throw himself in. Yet he also conceded multiple set pieces and committed late fouls that invited pressure. What stood out to us was how often he followed runners aggressively, sometimes leaving space behind. His late blocked effort in attack showed desire but also hinted at Fiorentina’s disjointed structure in the final minutes. Decent, but far from dominant.

João Mário - 6.5: The numbers paint him as tidy, and we saw that on the pitch. Ninety-five percent passing with 22 accurate passes tells you he rarely wasted possession. Defensively he chipped in with a tackle, an interception and some vital clearances under pressure. Still, Juventus found joy down his flank at times, especially on corners where his positioning looked slightly reactive. He also conceded a few corners that kept Fiorentina pinned back. From our perspective he delivered a functional, sensible outing rather than a truly standout performance.

Alejandro Jiménez Sánchez - 7: We really enjoyed watching Jiménez. His duel numbers are excellent, winning nine of eleven; it matched the eye test. He defended his side with three tackles and three clearances yet still pushed forward with purpose, creating two chances and delivering two crosses. One of those combinations led to Mastantuono’s dangerous effort, showing his timing in the final third. We noticed his balance between risk and security, even when Juventus targeted him with long diagonals. He fades slightly late on, but overall this was an impressive two-way display.

Viery - 5.5: This was a strange game for Viery and honestly a bit frustrating to watch. On the ball he was clean, hitting 93 percent of his passes and switching play with some sharp long balls. However, he lost six of seven duels and looked vulnerable whenever Juventus attacked his zone. That big chance he missed at 2-1 felt huge, the kind of moment that kills momentum. We noticed his body language dip afterward, shoulders slightly slumped, confidence shaken. It was not disastrous, but Fiorentina needed more authority from him in both boxes.

Midfielders

Alieu Njie - 8: For us, Alieu Njie was one of Fiorentina’s most influential performers. He scored a poacher’s goal from close range, attacking the loose ball with real hunger. Beyond the goal he took three shots, one on target, and constantly attacked the half-spaces. Defensively he was busy, winning two tackles and making four recoveries, even if he lost a few duels and passes. What stood out to us was his willingness to keep driving at defenders despite 16 possessions lost. That relentlessness, plus his decisive goal, justifies a strong rating.

Cher Ndour - 6.5: Ndour played one of those quietly important, slightly messy midfield games. He hit 82 percent passing, contributed five recoveries and three clearances, and offered one key pass. Yet he also missed two presentable efforts, especially that chance from the right side of the six-yard box. From our perspective he sometimes arrived half a second late into duels, getting dribbled past and losing four challenges. However he kept showing, kept making vertical runs, and never hid from responsibility. Solid, but his end product could have changed the game.

Pedro Gonçalves- 8.5: We had Pote as Fiorentina’s creative brain and arguably their best outfield player. He delivered a perfect corner for Pellegrino’s opener, then kept whipping dangerous balls with 100 percent cross accuracy. Four key passes and a big chance created underline his influence whenever Fiorentina advanced. We also noticed his work rate; two tackles and steady pressing showed he wasn’t just floating around. Yes, he conceded some fouls and was occasionally dribbled past, but the positives far outweighed that. In our book he shares the highest rating in this match.

Franco Mastantuono - 7: Mastantuono’s performance had real personality. He took five shots, constantly looking to test Vicario from distance. Two key passes and two chances created show he wasn’t just shooting on sight. Defensively he chipped in with four tackles and two interceptions, repeatedly snapping into midfield duels. We noticed he did get dribbled past a few times as Juventus broke quickly through the lines. Still, for such a young player, his confidence and intensity really stood out to us. A very encouraging all-round display.

Christ Inao Oulaï - 6: Oulaï’s numbers look immaculate in passing, and they matched what we saw. He completed every one of his 28 passes and handled Juventus’ press with calmness. Off the ball he made six recoveries and three tackles, anchoring midfield nicely in the first half. But the story turns with the repeated fouls and eventual yellow card that shifted momentum. We noticed Juventus targeting his zone once he was on a booking, drawing him into risky challenges. His early control gave way to indiscipline, which drags his rating down a little.

Forwards

Mateo Pellegrino - 8: This was a big, almost statement performance from Pellegrino. He scored a towering header after just four minutes, attacking Pote’s cross with conviction. Throughout the first half he bullied Juventus’ back line, winning fouls and taking four shots. We noticed his constant movement between the centre-backs, dragging Jhon Lucumí and Bremer into awkward areas. He did miss a couple of headers that could have killed the game, especially around the interval. Still, his goal, chance creation and work rate make this an undeniably strong showing.

Viery - 5.5: When pushed higher, Viery never quite found his rhythm. He took one shot and horribly missed a big chance from close range at 2-1. That moment lingered, because from our perspective the stadium felt ready to explode with a third goal. His aerial numbers were poor despite being frequently targeted, and he won just one duel all night. Passing remained sharp, but he contributed little threat between the lines. Overall it felt like a game that exposed his limitations higher up the pitch.

Substitutes

Nicolò Fagioli - 6.5: Coming in around the 65th minute, Fagioli added a bit of composure. He delivered the set-piece cross that Njie almost buried with another header. We noticed his willingness to get on the ball immediately, trying to calm Fiorentina after Bremer’s equaliser. He did concede a corner that kept Juventus on the front foot, which was a little careless. Still, his technique under pressure and quick progressive passes helped Fiorentina regain some control. For limited minutes, he made a respectable impact.

Marco Brescianini - 6: Brescianini’s entrance coincided with the game becoming more stretched. He didn’t have Pote’s creative spark but offered industry and simple passing. From our perspective he tried to plug gaps rather than break lines. Without detailed stats, it felt like a shift more about legs than ideas. He kept shape, pressed reasonably well and avoided major mistakes. An average cameo, nothing more, nothing less.

Manager

P. Vanoli - 6.5: Vanoli’s game plan worked brilliantly for 55 minutes. Fiorentina’s set-piece routines and wide overloads clearly targeted Juventus’ weaknesses, and we admired the bravery to push full-backs high. However, once Juventus adjusted with fresh legs, the response from the bench felt a bit slow. The decision to remove Pote when he was dictating so much play surprised us. His team still created enough to win, but the defensive structure wobbled on every Juventus corner. A mixed night, tactically sharp early but reactive late.

Juventus Player Ratings vs Fiorentina

Have a look at the Juventus player ratings from the Fiorentina vs Juventus player ratings.

Goalkeeper

Guglielmo Vicario - 6.5: Vicario’s night was about damage limitation more than heroics. He conceded two but had little chance with either close-range finish. His distribution looked assured, completing 16 of 19 passes and launching several accurate long balls. We noticed one excellent low save from Pellegrino, which kept Juventus alive at 2-1. Command of the box was adequate though not dominant, especially on early corners. Overall, a competent display that allowed others to drag Juventus back.

Defenders

Bremer - 7.5: Bremer had a chaotic but ultimately decisive performance. Defensively he struggled early, picking up a yellow card and losing several duels against Pellegrino. Yet he never shied away and grew into the game as Juventus pushed higher. His equalising goal from close range summed up his mentality, attacking Douglas Luiz’s cross with determination. We noticed him barking instructions constantly, trying to organise a back line under siege. Despite his flaws, his goal and leadership justify a strong rating.

Pierre Kalulu - 7: Kalulu quietly had one of the better outings among Juventus defenders. He completed 41 of 46 passes and wasn’t afraid to step into midfield with the ball. Defensively he won most of his duels and produced three clearances plus two tackles. From our perspective he read Fiorentina’s rotations well, particularly when Njie drifted inside. His only real blemish was conceding a couple of corners under pressure. Overall, this was a composed, modern centre-back display.

Jhon Lucumí - 5.5: This was a tough watch for Lucumí. He looked uncomfortable dealing with Fiorentina’s movement and long diagonals. His passing numbers are okay, but we noticed him losing three of four duels and misjudging aerials. One error led directly to a shot, which added to the sense of unease. He also missed a headed chance in the box that could have swung momentum. The injury scare early in the second half seemed to knock his rhythm further.

Juan Cabal - 6: Cabal’s 56 minutes were eventful. He picked up an early yellow, which forced him to tone down his aggression. Yet he still managed three shots, including two on target that forced De Gea into action. We liked his intensity and willingness to overlap, even under pressure. Defensively he won some duels but also conceded fouls in dangerous positions. Being substituted felt more like a protection decision than a punishment.

Midfielders

Teun Koopmeiners - 7: Koopmeiners orchestrated much of Juventus’ attacking flow. He delivered eight crosses, three of them accurate, and created three chances including one big one for McKennie. His set-piece delivery caused Fiorentina problems all night, culminating in the chaos that led to Bremer’s goal. We noticed him constantly demanding the ball, even after a few misplaced passes. Defensively he put in two tackles and an interception, though fouls in advanced areas stalled some counters. Overall, a strong creative performance that deserved even more.

Douglas Luiz - 7.5: Douglas Luiz quietly played a superb technical game. He completed 49 of 50 passes, an absurd 98 percent accuracy in midfield. His crossing also mattered, providing the assist for Bremer’s equaliser with a clever, flat delivery. He took three shots himself, including one from distance that just sailed over. We noticed how often he dropped between the centre-backs to help build under pressure. The only real blemish was a big chance missed with a header. Even with that, his control and vision were vital.

Jérémie Boga - 6.5: Boga’s 57 minutes were full of dribbles and half-moments. He completed three of five dribbles and drew four fouls, constantly turning defenders around. His link-up play with Koopmeiners and Kolo Muani on the left looked dangerous in spells. Yet his final ball wavered and he lost possession frequently, stalling some promising breaks. From our perspective he looked disappointed when substituted, as if he felt a goal was coming. A lively but inconsistent showing.

Weston McKennie - 6: McKennie’s game will probably be remembered for that big missed header. He otherwise had a mixed night, offering energy, eight crosses and some late runs into the box. However, only 69 percent pass completion and a key chance wasted hurt his overall value. We noticed his pressing and defensive positioning were solid, especially as Juventus chased the game. The substitution around 78 minutes felt right given his fading influence. An average performance with one glaring what-if moment.

Forwards

Randal Kolo Muani - 8: From our perspective Randal Kolo Muani was Juventus’ most dangerous player throughout. He assisted Nick Woltemade’s goal with a perfectly timed pass on the counter, and also played the cross leading to Cabal’s early chance. Four key passes, four successful dribbles and constant movement made him a nightmare to track. He did pick up a yellow card and committed several fouls, reflecting his aggressive edge. We noticed his off-ball work too, dropping deep to help link midfield and attack. Overall, he fully justified a high rating and was right in the man-of-the-match conversation.

Nick Woltemade - 8.5: For us, Nick Woltemade was the standout performer and highest-rated player on the pitch. His equalising goal at 1-1 was a textbook centre-forward finish, low into the corner with minimal backlift. Beyond the goal he linked play beautifully, winning seven of ten duels and contributing a key pass. His movement repeatedly dragged Fiorentina’s centre-backs out of shape, creating lanes for runners. We noticed his frustration when substituted, but it felt more about desire than ego. With three shots, two on target, and relentless work-rate, this was a complete centre-forward display.

Substitutes

Zeki Çelik - 6.5: Çelik came on and immediately tightened Juventus’ right side. He won a key defensive free kick and later assisted the shot from Kerim Alajbegovic with a smart pass. We noticed his positional discipline, rarely overcommitting even when Juventus chased a winner. Offensively he picked his moments, providing one measured cross. For limited minutes, he did exactly what his coach needed.

Edon Zhegrova - 6.5: Zhegrova added spark in attacking zones. He delivered a clever cross for Douglas Luiz’s headed chance, showing his vision. We saw him drifting into pockets, trying to pull Fiorentina’s defence narrow. He conceded one foul and occasionally overcomplicated dribbles, but the intent was positive. Overall he changed the rhythm of Juventus’ attack in a subtle but noticeable way.

Kerim Alajbegovic - 6: Alajbegovic’s cameo was a miniature rollercoaster. He produced a good right-footed effort that De Gea had to save low. However he also committed fouls and even a handball that slowed Juventus’ late momentum. We noticed his willingness to shoot and attack space immediately, which at least kept Fiorentina honest. For us this was an uneven but energetic contribution.

Jeff Ekhator - 6: Ekhator had a late headed chance which he sent off target. His physical presence did help Juventus sustain pressure, especially on long balls and second phases. We noticed his pressing intensity, closing down Fiorentina’s centre-backs aggressively. Yet with limited time he could not quite put his stamp on proceedings. A typical impact-sub cameo, full of effort but lacking the final touch.

Manager

L. Spalletti - 7: Spalletti will probably leave frustrated but also quietly satisfied. His team started poorly, misreading Fiorentina’s set-piece threat and losing early battles. However, the in-game adjustments and substitutions flipped the momentum. Introducing Woltemade centrally and later Zhegrova and Çelik gave Juventus more structure and creativity. From our perspective he won the touchline duel in the second half, especially with set-piece emphasis that delivered both goals. A point on the road against an aggressive Fiorentina, with this many chances created, reflects well on his decisions.